Spang Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Spang bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent in Spang courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Negligent driving results in conviction

who's talking here?

RoxAnne 3
Rachel 3
Renee 1
mckenzie 2
Marco 1
Kristen 2
RoadTripQueen 2
Aaron 3
J3nnif3r 5
badstreetusa 1
Jason 2
Kristie 1
Amy 1
YeahRight 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

RoxAnne --- 15 years ago -

4/20/2011 - SPANGDAHLEM AIR BASE, Germany -- Airman 1st Class Alan J. Lindgren, 52nd Logistics Readiness Squadron, was found guilty of two specifications of negligent homicide in violation of Article 134, Uniform Code of Military Justice April 6 at the 52nd Fighter Wing Legal Office Court room.

Airman Lindgren elected to be tried and sentenced by a military judge instead of a panel of officers. Colonel Dawn R. Eflein, Chief Trial Judge for the European Region, sentenced the accused to 15 months confinement and reduction to the grade of E-2.

The accused was driving his BMW M-3 on the autobahn when he lost control of his vehicle and killed two Spangdahlem Airmen, A1C Amanda J. Jotham and A1C Brandon S. McDonald July 11, 2010. The car crash occurred on the A-60 between Spangdahlem Air Base and Bitburg, Germany.

At trial, the prosecution introduced evidence of the high speed, approximately 240 kmh, the accused was driving at the time he lost control of his vehicle. Although the stretch of autobahn where the crash occurred did not have a posted speed limit, the accused was found to be negligent and therefore legally responsible for the consequences of his actions.

A conviction for negligent homicide requires the prosecution to prove beyond a reasonable doubt the accused's actions, which caused the death of another, amounted to simple negligence. Simple negligence is a failure to act as a reasonable person would have acted under similar circumstances. In order to meet their burden of proof, the prosecution focused on the high speed of the vehicle at the sharp curve where the crash occurred and the extreme reclined position of the driver's seat as factors that indicated Airman Lindgren did not act as a reasonable person would have acted.

Airman Lindgren is currently serving his sentence at the U.S. Army Regional Corrections Facility - Europe in Mannheim, Germany.


http://www.spangdahlem.af.mil/news/story.asp?id=123252454 

RoxAnne --- 15 years ago -

I usually stay out of these discussions BUT a little over a year for killing two people???? 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

Wow, I agree, RoxAnne, seems low. But I am not sure what kind of sentence people usually get, like in civilian court... 

YeahRight --- 15 years ago -

Unbelievable and disgusting! 

badstreetusa --- 15 years ago -

He got off very light... 

J3nnif3r --- 15 years ago -

I get up to 200kph in my husband's little sports car and that's as fast as I'll push it. (and that's ONLY on the straight stretches...) I can't imagine trying to take that curve at 240!! That's just asking to kill yourself. 

Aaron --- 15 years ago -

I'm not saying I agree or disagree with the sentencing, but I can't help but wonder if the same punishment would have been handed down if it were, for example, a SMSgt in a comparable vehicle in a comparable seating position. 

J3nnif3r --- 15 years ago -

Any factor could be thrown in there for the same scenario...

What if it were an officer... a FEMALE officer... a black airman... a female SNCO... (see what I'm getting at?)

I'm sure rank might have had something to do with it, but we'll never know the circumstances because we're just outside parties looking in. 

Jason --- 15 years ago -

15 months confinement is a long time to sit in a cell and think about the people you accidentally killed. I imagine he will be haunted by this the rest of his life, no punishment could be worse than that. 

Aaron --- 15 years ago -

True. Again, I'm not one way or the other on his punishment. I think whatever the Judge decided was for the best. But it does seem like age and gender play a huge role in judicial and non-judicial punishments lately. The numbers justify it though. It's been the young males effin' up for as long as I can remember.
I guess it doesn't make a lot of sense to me based on the vague facts presented in the above article. Is there an AFI or a local law stating how far back a seat can be? He was being dangerous, but wasn't breaking any speed laws (this is assuming he had Z-rated [149mph+) tires). And again, I'm not saying the punishment was right or wrong--just wondering. 

RoadTripQueen --- 15 years ago -

What if military ranks wasn't a factor at all and a civilian who just wrecklessly killed 2 people? If one of those victims was my child, I would be so distraught to be honest that he only received 15 months. You're right Jason, this will haunt him the rest of HIS life, but he IS ALIVE and the one who drove the car and not the 2 passengers he was responsible for that he killed. I do not feel sorry for him one bit. 

RoadTripQueen --- 15 years ago -

Actually Aaron, if you drive 120+kmh on an Autobahn and cause an accident or even kill an animal I believe, you are automatically at fault and subject to fines, penalties, etc. 

mckenzie --- 15 years ago -

he didnt get off with just the sentance he had to do more then that. its not all posted in that story. and since that day he has had nothing but regret. this is why i hate news stories it only tells what they want you to hear and not the full truth. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

I suspect that there are many reasons he opted to be judged and tried the way he did. I just really hope this teaches people that going that fast is not a great idea.

I am sure he will live with this his whole life and may very well ruin his future. I am sorry that he made choices like that and I am sure he does wish he could take them back.

What I hope is that he moves forward in his life and steps to a higher ground and this has such an impact that instead of falling down and being a mess after all is said and done he finds a way to inspire people, be a good example, and live a life that involves much more. 

J3nnif3r --- 15 years ago -

I'm not going to believe that more was dealt to this airman... If there was, it wasn't sufficient enough to be mentioned so it wasn't "enough."

I think I'm done believing crap that ANYONE says in this manner of rumor - because if I recall, someone stated that the airman who died recently had passed away from meningitis?! (sorry to laugh at your LIE, but.... he died after he had been found HUFFING in his room.) 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

McKenzie, of course a news article never tells all the details, but the sentence is fact and can be discussed objectively. If someone I knew was in a situation like this and it was being publicly talked about, I would just steer clear of all the conversations, because it would be too aggravating/hurtful/infuriating to hear it talked about by strangers. 

Kristie --- 15 years ago -

I was wondering about this the other day, I remember that day like it was yesterday. I was at work but didn't go to the wreck (thank goodness).

And J3nn, I learned that the other day but wasn't going to say anything because others will claim it's just a rumor. 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

Why do people always want to have first-hand knowledge and throw it out there into the public domain, when something tragic or scandalous happens (not talking about J3n or Kristie). So strange. Like I said before, if something happened to someone I actually KNEW and cared about, I would stay away from all public conversations about it. If you really know and care about the people involved, you shouldn't want to air their private business, even if it is to stop a rumor or save their good name. You do better by them by refusing to participate in the hubbub at all. I think it is just the people that kinda, maybe, sorta know OF the person, or know somebody who knows somebody who worked with them two years ago or used to be their neighbor, or once stood behind them in line, that feel entitled to spill the 'facts' they overhead in private into the public domain.

So, if something terrible happens to me, those of you that actually know me, please don't come on here and try to tell all the details to 'set sh1t straight.' I would rather people speculate, even if it is unfavorable, than have my actual friends and family give out my private details. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

Ok, that thing you did last week then--remember? I won't have your back girl. Just know that. I am not defending you.

Kidding of course, I agree with your point. It is hard to but it is best to stay away from situations that are too close to home 

mckenzie --- 15 years ago -

well rachel if you are talking about me i didnt give out any info i just know there is more to the story. it just drives me nuts how nothing ever tells the whole story. and that is with everything. 

Aaron --- 15 years ago -

I think I'm done believing crap that ANYONE says in this manner of rumor - because if I recall, someone stated that the airman who died recently had passed away from meningitis?! (sorry to laugh at your LIE, but.... he died after he had been found HUFFING in his room.) 

@Jennifer: Where was this published? I haven't seen anything in print/email at all. Is it a...rumor?
Plus, if we were to go through this site and delete everything that YOU said in a "manner of rumor", your presence would be almost nonexistent here. You're an NCO and you know how detrimental rumors can be to a unit. If this huffing comment is a rumor, I think it's very irresponsible and uncharacteristic of an NCO to post them here. Just sayin'. 

Renee --- 15 years ago -

I think the entire situation is tragic. This kid made a really, really bad choice, killed two people and has to live with that. I really don't know if the sentence is enough or not, but his life has certainly been permanently changed by this, as have the lives of the families of the deceased. I think honestly, the best that can come from this is for command to use it as an example to young airman about the consequences of making bad choices and not thinking before they act. 

J3nnif3r --- 15 years ago -

You can bet that if his huffing were merely a rumor, I wouldn't be stating it... Just like I didn't go out there and say he died of meningitis... 

Amy --- 15 years ago -

I think I'm done believing crap that ANYONE says in this manner of rumor - because if I recall, someone stated that the airman who died recently had passed away from meningitis?! (sorry to laugh at your LIE, but.... he died after he had been found HUFFING in his room.)


Wow....you're the first one to complain about "people starting rumors", then you spout off that crap?! He died of MENINGITIS! All the guys in his shop were given antobiotics for it immediately following his death. He was in the hospital for 2 days BEFORE he even died! You really need to learn some respect! Not everyone is a drug addict or a screw up. You're the first one telling people to STFU when they don't know what they are talking about, why don't you follow your own advice for a change?! 

RoxAnne --- 15 years ago -

So I wonder if this Airman's 15 months start now or if he was already being held and that counts towards time served...if so he will be out in time to enjoy the Holidays....how nice. UGH!

Is there an AFI or a local law stating how far back a seat can be? He was being dangerous, but wasn't breaking any speed laws (this is assuming he had Z-rated [149mph+) tires). And again, I'm not saying the punishment was right or wrong--just wondering.
Interesting...I didn't even think of that... 

J3nnif3r --- 15 years ago -

I wonder if the "reclined position" of the seat was intentional - or if it was flattened with impact of the crash? Or maybe he leaned it back in order to help himself get out of the car?

Not trying to defend the kid... just sayin' 

Jason --- 15 years ago -

I was in a car accident in which the seat collapsed. I don't know if it was designed to do it or not but it saved my life.

At 150mph he would have a hard time controlling his vehicle in any seat position. 

Marco --- 15 years ago -

Wow....you're the first one to complain about "people starting rumors", then you spout off that crap?! He died of MENINGITIS!

It's not a rumour. Not at all. Don't ask me how I know, because it really is a moot point at this stage of the game. And frankly, it is really none of your business how I know.

Funny. I remember when this accident occured. And I posted what I had heard. More than one person went up one side of me, and down the other. Tore the proverbial strip off me. "Rumours", they proclaimed.
Well, if you hunt back into the postings and find the original post, you will see what I had said was true.

One item which was omitted in this report: the driver had his liscence taken away in the past due to driving offences. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Spang Underground