Spang Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Spang bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent in Spang courtesy of Military Real Estate!

This is a tough one - peanut allergy.

who's talking here?

RoxAnne 1
Rachel 1
billieann 1
cjone2000 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

cjone2000 --- 15 years ago -

What is your reaction to this story? I'm on the fence on this one. On one hand I feel sorry for the little girl, on the other hand, I can see parents of the other kids frustrated too.

Homeschool 1st Grader Because of Severe Peanut Allergy???

I don't have kids yet, but my concern mainly would be if another kids forgot to wash his/her hands or had peanut butter undetectable on his/her clothes and caused this little girl to go into shock and die. How borrible and traumatic would that be. Not sure on the solution of this one, but thought it would something interesting to bring up. 

billieann --- 15 years ago -

Personally if it were my child, I would home school her. That's just because I wouldn't trust every child and teacher to be as careful as needed. The poor teacher has enough on their hands to worry about without the extra stress of a child having an allergic reaction. 

RoxAnne --- 15 years ago -

Well if I was the parent of a child who had to accommodate her I would be okay with the washing of the hands. BUT, rinsing out their mouth...That seems like a bit much. I have a friend who has to take snacks to her sons school once a month. They have a list of food items they can not bring because of allergies.

This is a tough one though. 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

I have known more than one family who had a child with immune problems, usually as a complication of another illness (like cancer). There were times when that child did not come to school, either because they immunity was especially low due to recent treatment or illness, or because there was a high rate of illness in the classroom. Either way, the parents made that choice, sometimes keeping the kid at home for weeks.
The peanut allergy thing is not the same, but similar. The school cannot say she can't go there, but the parents can, and I think should, make that decision themselves. Not forever, but until she is old enough and responsible enough to be able to keep herself safe at school, and she isn't with little kids who run around with peanut butter all over themselves :) 

cjone2000 --- 15 years ago -

Some people are upset with the parents that were "protesting" saying they aren't compassionate enough and such. The girl is protected under federal law to have a right to an education. In support of the little girl, the kids are better off to learn better hygiene and be considerate of other people.

However, the other students are subjected to multiple hand washes (not so bad) but the mouth rinsing is a bit weird along with the peanut butter sniffing dog. The rights of the kids at that school to eat peanut butter is taken away for this one little girl. Classroom education time is taken away everytime a snack is eaten in the classroom and at lunchtime to ensure all the kids in her class wash their mouths and hands. The teacher becomes responsible for being the peaunt police. Heaven forbid the little girl has a reaction at school. Will her parents sue the school, the teacher, or even the parents of the kid(s) who brought peanuts into school accidentally?

But I still feel bad for the little girl, she has to live with the allergy probably for the rest of her life. Kids in her school may already resent her having to constantly wash their hands, and not eat anything with peanuts or cooked with peanut oil. She's going to have a tough time being in the public too. You can't make people in malls, libraries, movie theaters, grocery stores, and more from having peanuts. She's probably going to go to college and and get a job when she's older. At that point, no one is going to want to comply or be required to comply with a no peanut policy.

I also have to wonder what her parents think about putting her in a place where there still is no control over other kids in other classrooms/grades could have peanut butter or peanut products in the school that puts her at risk. Seems to me that if an allergy is that bad and that deadly, it's a huge risk to have her in a public or even private school. They can really only control the environment in their home. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

children
health
news

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Spang Underground