Spang Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Spang bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent in Spang courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Tattle Re-attack

who's talking here?

Rachel 1
Renee 1
denver21 1
WitnessProtectionProgram 1
Kristen 1
J3nnif3r 3
Kristie 2
Tiffanie 1
Tiffany 1
Ilumine 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

J3nnif3r --- 15 years ago -

I know this was talked about in a previous post... but I can't remember everything that was said, and maybe some newer lurkers have different ideas?

My 8 yr old brought her progress report home from school today. She excels in EVERYTHING except life skills (and the teacher highlighted that she hasn't quite developed in certain areas...) When we communicated via email the other day, he'd made mention that she's still tattling at school. (ie, today... he asked if the children had washed their hands, and my little informant took it upon herself to correct the class, who had apparently misinformed the teacher, that in fact NONE of the kids had actually washed their hands.) Of course, my kid gets all confused, she didn't understand! She wasn't tattling on ONE person in particular (so she says...) We try to say well no, but you told on the WHOLE CLASS, which is worse!

I've tried to tell her to leave EVERYTHING to the teacher, unless it's life threatening. If someone is choking or bleeding or anything like that, then get help. Otherwise, NOTHING is your business, unless someone is causing you bodily harm. She just doesn't get it!

She's always been made to follow the rules and be fair at home... so she takes that mentality and tries to impose it on everyone around her. Unfortunately, she needs to learn from life that equality just doesn't exist. I don't know about you guys, but I personally think that life skills isn't an area that needs "grading" at school. Life skills are JUST THAT - skills that are acquired by living! I think that if the teacher is bothered by tattling, then he should just turn his cheek (I mean, isn't that what the majority of parents do when they get sick of our kids tattling on one another?) 

Kristie --- 15 years ago -

If you figure out how to stop it let me know. Our 9 almost 10yr old still tattles. I told her unless someone is hurt the teacher doesn't need to be told. But she still thinks she has too, seems to go in one ear and out the other. 

Kristie --- 15 years ago -

Oh yea, I didn't even know they graded on that stuff. I've never seen a report card with so many different things graded on it. 

J3nnif3r --- 15 years ago -

She's got excellent marks in everything... she's one of the top readers/spellers in her class - is a whiz at math and science. I'm honestly not going to let the tattling thing bother me TOO much. It's something I think they'll learn with time/age. Some things, kids just have to experience for themselves ya know? 

denver21 --- 15 years ago -

Mike Brady's Pearls of Wisdom 

Ilumine --- 15 years ago -

I think that the teacher is concerned that your daughter's lack of "life skills" will ultimately do her harm socially. If you can correct this before she becomes the focus of the class sort of thing. I have a socially awkward teenage boy, my SS. He too was a tattle teller, though for different reasons. His school life sucked/sucks. It started with some innocuous behaviors that pissed off his classmates and spiraled from there. It took PCSing here to cut the cycle. We tried letting him learn from his own actions, but that only made it worse. We actually had to DEMAND that he did or did not do certain things in school, socially, or punish him. Absolutely SUCKS that we had to go that route, BUT his social life is 80% better than it was before. 

J3nnif3r --- 15 years ago -

She seems to be doing great. She has her own circle of friends, doesn't complain about too many kids picking on her or anything like that.

I just don't know how to change her mindset... I need for her to understand that life isn't fair - but it's our PERSONAL job to do the right thing when no one is looking. Not everyone is going to do the right thing... but if we watch out for ourselves, that's the BEST thing.

Then again, she's 8. She has a little time to learn! 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

Kids have different personalities, you know? I think we are so into trying to make everyone 'the same' now, starting with children. They have their quirks and eccentricities; for some, it is an obsession with fairness and a habit of tattling. Oh well. These things used to take care of themselves, as kids would see how their actions affected their 'social lives' and interactions with others, then choose to change, or not. That would be the point you would intervene, when the kid is requesting help: mom, ppl at school don't like me. Why? Because I tell on them. What can I do? Help me!
But seems like she is okay with it, so hey, let it be. As far as the teacher, the one who really has a problem with it, UGH. I am so tired of teachers who do next to nothing in the way of discipline in their classrooms. They need to have their own consequences on place, be creative and flexible with problems that arise, and ignore the little crap. Grading on life skills? Sounds to me like a clever way to document any behavior problems or weirdness to cover the school's butt later. Hilarious. That is the kind of stuff we used to just mention in the comments, maybe, or at a conference. Seems so silly to make a big deal of it. 

WitnessProtectionProgram --- 15 years ago -

I told my kids that unless it had to do something with them or another person get's hurt to leave it alone UNLESS they are asked. Then they are never, ever to lie about it. So when I see your daughter telling the teacher the TRUTH about something they were asked, I do not see that as an example of tattling. I'm confused why the teacher would see it this way. When she knows something to be a lie, then by all means, speak up! I would rather have an honest tattle teller on my hands then a liar for a child. I've met quite a few of them and they are not the most pleasant children.

Tell the teacher that she's not tattle telling on people, she's just "saturating him with honesty". HAHA. Kidding. 

Tiffanie --- 15 years ago -

DOD teachers are ridiculous. My son's teacher complains that he asks too many questions. They seem incapable of handling any child that does not fit into their cookie cutter mold. She'll figure when it's appropriate to tell and when it's not in time. I wouldn't worry about it. 

Renee --- 15 years ago -

I agree with Masterchef. If they were asked a direct question, and your daughter told the truth despite any negative consequences, she should be praised, not reprimanded. It would be different if she had run up to the teacher and just said, "Hey, no body washed their hands" But the teacher asked and should expect the truth. There should have been consequences for the kids who lied. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

my SS

what is that?

I think we are so into trying to make everyone 'the same' now, starting with children.

agreed

Grading on life skills?

I mean, home ec, shop, auto hobby shop, budgeting, etc (things for older kids) that is an actual CLASS at that point......

that actually makes me kind of sad--ok VERY sad, let's tell this kid she is socially inept NOW, yeah, when she is trying to find herself......find her own personality........

can't the teacher just say 'why thank you dear' --I say stuff like that to our son all the time--then I say, no need to address it, but thanks for the info--now I know.......but you need to DROP it then (him drop it I mean) and if it needs further addressing that is up to ME not him.

I do not see that as an example of tattling. I'm confused why the teacher would see it this way. When she knows something to be a lie, then by all means, speak up!

yes 

Tiffany --- 15 years ago -

I agree with Masterchef. If they were asked a direct question, and your daughter told the truth despite any negative consequences, she should be praised, not reprimanded. It would be different if she had run up to the teacher and just said, "Hey, no body washed their hands" But the teacher asked and should expect the truth. There should have been consequences for the kids who lied.

agreed. also, i have mixed feelings about tattling. i don't want my kid running to me for every little thing, but i don't want them to think its ok to fight with friends/classmates. i want my child to come to me when there is conflict so he doesn't learn that fighting is ok. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Spang Underground