Spang Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Spang bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent in Spang courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Parenting

who's talking here?

Rachel 5
Renee 2
Kristen 3
Jaymee 1
jacinta 1
LaurenB 1
J3nnif3r 2
Tiffanie 1
Tiffany 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

Okay, first, read this article: Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior. Now, I don't agree with the parenting techniques this woman advocates, but I did find some of what she said about "Western" style parenting to be true. Specifically,

They worry about how their children will feel if they fail at something, and they constantly try to reassure their children about how good they are notwithstanding a mediocre performance on a test or at a recital.

and

Western parents worry a lot about their children's self-esteem. But as a parent, one of the worst things you can do for your child's self-esteem is to let them give up. On the flip side, there's nothing better for building confidence than learning you can do something you thought you couldn't.

Sometimes I think American parents treat children the way they think they would want to be treated, but that is from an adult perspective. Meaning, we treat them like little adults who already have all kinds of issues and knowledge about themselves, which they don't have. I personally don't think it is wrong to have certain high expectations of your children. You as a parent should know what they are capable of, and expect that of them. There is an educational theory about this called "self-fulfilling prophecy" that basically states that children will meet your expectations, no matter how low or high. So if you expect virtually nothing of them, tell them, well try your best but it's fine it you fail miserably, then that is exactly what they will do.

Thoughts? 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

Really? Nobody? LOL

Okay, what about the idea that we don't have as much of an affect on our children's self-esteem as we think we do? Self-esteem and confidence come from becoming good at something, from succeeding in the face of difficulty or obstacle. If we just shower our kids with praise all the time, tell them how wonderful and perfect and special they are, just the way they are, just for being themselves, they have no motivation to try at anything. There is some thinking that this kind of empty praise keeps them from ever attempting a challenge, partly because they don't want to disappoint us, but also because they are scared of anything hard. By trying so hard to give them self-confidence, we actually do the opposite.

Anybody? You don't have to be a parent to have opinion; we were all raised in way or another, so maybe you have opinions based on your own experiences growing up. 

Tiffanie --- 15 years ago -

I'll bite:-) I agree that in our culture we seem to praise our kids too much. Take sports for example. Everyone gets to play no matter how good they are, everyone gets a trophy and now, some places aren't even keeping score. That teaches our kids that they get all the reward with little effort. There's nothing wrong with kids having to work hard to accomplish something and being honest with them when they aren't performing up to their potential. I call my older boys out on this. I want them to have pride in hard work. 

J3nnif3r --- 15 years ago -

With my oldest, I encourage her to try new things. BUT - whatever she chooses to try, she has to carry through to the end.

Horseback riding lessons - ok, she didn't go all the way to the end... but she went until she fell off and was too scared to continue.

Ballet - she went from the start of one season to the recital at the end.

Soccer - start to finish.

Piano - start to recital.

The other day, her teacher asked for volunteers for the school spelling bee - he needed two from her class. I HIGHLY encouraged, but told her I wouldn't force it. At first, she was afraid. She didn't want to fail. I told her that EVERYONE would fail - except the winner :P And she'll never have the chance to win if she doesn't try!

I hate that they didn't keep score in soccer. I hate that EVERYONE got a medal. Competition is a HEALTHY part of life! 

Jaymee --- 15 years ago -

We refused to buy the extra trophy for our son when he did soccer the other parents were mad at us. 

J3nnif3r --- 15 years ago -

I'm a firm believer in if you want the gold, you gotta GO FOR IT!

I hate this whole "equal and fair" mindset that America is tryign to instill... Everyone is the same.. blah blah blah. If that were true, everyone would be paid the same, everyone would be entitled to the same luxuries/hardships, etc. But no - you have to FIGHT for the best... and you WANT to win. (I don't know anyone who wants to lose...) But for these kids who don't know what losing is, well... how bad is it going to be when they really do? 

LaurenB --- 15 years ago -

I agree with what everyone is saying...Americans are spoiled in a lot of ways and hard work is what built our country up... 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

Yes, Lauren, and I read a comment on this article by an older gentleman about that. He said something about all that we accomplished as a country in his time, but now the kids are all "nambly pambly" and that is why we are going to lose to China, lol.

I see this daily already with my three-year-old. I will suddenly, accidentally, discover that he can totally do something that I have been doing for him. It can be frustrating, but I am learning to have more confidence in his abilities and let him do more on his own. It's great :) 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

Here is my input. I agree :)

I have been told before that I push our son academically sometimes. I know he can do it, or I would not.

I also expect a lot out of him when it comes to personal accountability. 

jacinta --- 15 years ago -

Cruel, overbearing, demanding, unsupportive, delusional, unrealistic, mean, smothering, etc..
All words used at some time or another by some well meaning friend or relative to describe my parenting style--because I have expectations.
I have expectations because I love my kids and want them to become capable, competent adults.
I grew up in a home where there was no such thing as ambition. College was a pipe dream for "yuppies" and "orientals" = Never Gonna Happen. I know that kind of mentality causes far more damage to a childs self worth than parents who push for excellence.
All the warm, cuddly self esteem sessions little Britney and Joshy get from Mommy and Daddy today aren't going to pay the bills tomorrow...and neither is that job at Taco Bell. 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

Yum, Taco Bell :) My favorite saying: Hey, I haven't had a tummy ache in awhile-let's go to Taco Bell! Seriously, I like Taco Bell. I don't know why.

Anywho, this is gonna probably make some people mad, but I find it very strange to accept anything other than A's in public elementary school- that crap is EASY. If a child is not getting A's, then they either have a learning disability or they aren't trying hard enough. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

oh my niece got A's for a while, because the teacher did not want to get fired for her kids NOT getting A's the year prior.....

it is a big ol' mess..........so, just because they are getting A's they still may not know the material.......

anyhooo, that is another topic

but yeah, even I cry STILL when I don't get an A........still after all these years.....my parents expected me to try my hardest, always 

Renee --- 15 years ago -

Sorry I'm jumping in so late on this one ladies. My two cents: For the most part I agree with everything you guys have already said. I don't think encouragement and positive reinforcement is all bad, but I DO think that Americans and modern western society take it way too far. We do tend to coddle and "encourage" our kids into complete idiocy, and then we all wonder why kids these days have no common sense.

As far as sports and such things go, I think kids need to finish what they start. If they don't like it, then finish the season and be done, if they love it, well, keep it up. As for keeping score, etc.: My daughter played soccer this fall. She is 5 and it was her first experience with a team sport. It was tough for her in many ways - keeping focused, being tired from practice, sore feet (she has flat feet) etc. She wanted to quit a few times, but we told her she had to finish until the end, and then she didn't have to play next year if she didn't want to. She toughed it out and ended up having a lot of fun. They didn't keep score at the games, everyone got trophies and medals. I thought that this helped encourage their efforts and not just the "win" ideal. It doesn't mean they weren't being held accountable, they worked pretty hard for five year olds. The scorers did get special recognition, which was completely appropriate, but appreciation was shown for everyone on the team, even my daughter, who's best contribution was her good humor. I thought this was appropriate for the age group. As they get older, of course, there should be increased expectations. 

Renee --- 15 years ago -

Oh, and as for the article on Chinese mothers. I think there is definitely something to be said for their parenting, but I think it goes too far. I would propose a happy medium between Chinese and Western style parenting. The main difference I see here though, is that Chinese mother's put a lot of time and effort into their children, whereas Americans have a predominent tendency to just let kids raise themselves, and encourage their children a lot to make up for their own lack of real interest and attention. 

Tiffany --- 15 years ago -

Americans have a predominent tendency to just let kids raise themselves, and encourage their children a lot to make up for their own lack of real interest and attention.
Well said Renee. I find myself getting mad at both myself and my husband. I will look at him and get angry when something needs to be done relating to the kids then I go, damn, why aren't i getting up? then i get mad at myself and get up and do it. I like alot of Americans tend to get lazy...much more so since I've become a SAHM, I used to tackle the world when I worked and went to school etc almost tirelessly, not sure what happened there...but i digress. My point is that parents must make an effort for kids to be successful but only to a point. My own mother has a PHD and came from a line of other professionals and college graduates therefore alot was expected from me. Her input was minimal with the exception of looking over and/or correcting my work. We spend little one on one time. I remember coming home and being excited that i was in the top 2% of scorers on the high school competency test. My mom said, DUH, you should be. You are above average intelligence, the least you should expect is to score exceptionally well on a test that allows you to graduate high school. I thought it was cruel at the time. Then I became a parent. I totally get it now and even with my husband, try not to praise too much for people doing what they should be doing in the first place. Its the above and beyond stuff that deserves praise. If DH had it his way I'd be hanging a medal around his neck once a month or so when he decideds to help with the dishes and talk about it for weeks to follow. Who told people that they were supposed to be awarded for everything they do? Not my kids....not even. 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

I would propose a happy medium between Chinese and Western style parenting.

So the answer here, like so many things in life, appears to be moderation. I think Americans have lost sight of parenting, well, of life in general. Most have no plan, no general outline for how they want things to go. They just accept what happens to them day by day, taking no initiative or responsibility for the outcome. This kind of approach to parenting makes no sense- you end up just reacting to everything in a haphazard way instead of taking an active role in raising your children. You feel out of control because you are, and your children pick up on this and don't feel secure. No, you can't plan everything. But failing to plan is planning to fail, for real. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

I think that a lot of people have a plan. I think that sometimes it ends up being unrealistic, or the plan fails, then maybe they get flustered and give up.

I like to have a plan a, a plan b, and a plan c.

I think that until you have experienced many years of life, marriage, and parenting, that you really don't realize how flexible you have to be.

A plan is one thing, but plans change a lot.

I am not saying that your plan for discipline or for your child's education, or for your financial future should just be thrown to the wind, but I think that sometimes what we feel is ideal changes over time.

That is just me 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

children

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Spang Underground