Spang Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Spang bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent in Spang courtesy of Military Real Estate!

9yr old lying, need help... advice... whatever you can offer

who's talking here?

RoxAnne 1
Rachel 2
Kristen 3
Jaymee 2
LaurenB 1
J3nnif3r 6
badstreetusa 4
Kristie 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Kristie --- 15 years ago -

My 9yr old SD is not a bad child but she just lies about things. Last weekend she lied about brushing her teeth the week before. He punishment was to read articles online about what happens if you don't brush and to wirte what she learned. Well, today we caught her again not brushing her teeth the past week. I asked her when she brushed them last and she said last night. When I told her that I noticed her tooth brush and toothpaste haven't been in her bathroom her response was "really? I'll go check." I know she knew better ans she swore she learned her leason last weekend after spending all day reading about all the bad things. She even went as far as preaching to her mom and grandma about how bad not brushing was and she goes off and does it again.Any suggestioins? It's Christmas eve and she is grounded to her room and all she can do is read. How long should she be grounded for? She also got one of her presents taken away.I just don't know how to get it in her head that it's important to brush and bad for your health not too. Aparently writing a paper on it didn't help.I should add each time she was asked about brushing her teeth she lied and said she has been. 

badstreetusa --- 15 years ago -

First, I'd examine her gums and teeth and or take her to the dentist. She may be in pain and scared to brush and scared to admit it or scared of the dentist. Had a similar issue with my daugter not brushing. She had a really sensitive area on the gum line. I rehashsed brushing with her and threatened a trip to the dentist that would include "shots in the mouth"...no more issues. 

J3nnif3r --- 15 years ago -

I've got an 8 yr old who will never lie to me again. Once, in the shower... she zipped right through it and didn't bother to use shampoo or body wash. How do I know? Because the hair was BARELY touched and the washcloth was still dry. When I asked her, she swore to me that she did it and when I proved her wrong she didn't have anything left but to tell the truth. What did I do? I busted her butt with a belt. I told my daughter that the ONLY thing she would ever get a spanking like that for was for lying becuase I simply will not tolerate it. (prior to that, I'd asked her to finish the apple that she'd asked for... when I left the room, she threw 8 slices in the trash and when I came back 5 minutes later she smiled and said "all done.") YEAH RIGHT!

9 yr olds aren't too old for a little humiliation. At this point, you're punishing for lying, not for not brushing her teeth. The BIGGER lesson is lying. Right now she lies about the teeth, but what happens in 6 short years when she's a teenager and she starts sneaking out to drink or smoke weed? (and don't say my kid would never... because you and I BOTH know that we have no idea what our kids have in store.)

I'm not saying bust your kids butt... It worked for mine, it may not work for everyones.

Hmmm... if I were you... Grounding doesn't work, because she's in her room doing what she loves (reading.) Taking away reading is a bad choice because you WANT your kids to do that. I think if it were my kid, I'd threaten her with her Christmas gifts... If she doesn't start brushing her teeth, let her open EVERY SINGLE GIFT, and then she'd have to leave them in the package out in the open where she'll have to look at them and crave to use/play with them but won't be able to until she learns to tell the truth.

As for brushing... get a timer, and go to the bathroom with her. At 9, she should be granted the privacy and freedom to prove her responsibility, but she's clearly shown she can't do that... so "humiliate" her by standing over her shoulder while she does it. When she gains your trust back, then let her do it on her own again. It's a pain in the butt for you to have to accompany her... but you're teaching a lesson. 

J3nnif3r --- 15 years ago -

Oh yeah.. and if push comes to shove, brush her teeth FOR her. My daughter hates that lol 

LaurenB --- 15 years ago -

Hmm this sounds like me...the lying part anyways...when I was a kid I lied about everything...I have no clue why either...I don't lie now but my mom would ask me if I did a chore...a popular one, the cat pan, and without hesitation I would say, "yes" (I hadn't). The punishment I remember getting is writing sentences, but I always thought that was stupid/pointless. I would say grounding would be more effective or take away something important (video game/tv?) I don't have a 9yr old but that's just my suggestion from experience...she should grow out of it no worries :)

If all else fails you could have someone from SPUG call your house and threaten her to keep those puppies brushed!! lol 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

I like Jen's last suggestion, that you monitor every time while she does it, and maybe add in some other things to monitor too, until she gains back your trust and proves she will do it on her own.

It is a silly thing to lie about, but usually when kids lie about stuff like this, and go out of their way to avoid basic responsibilities, it is because they are trying to control the situation. They want something to control in their lives, something to feel like they are making the decision about. It happens around that age because they are feeling like they don't get to be in charge of anything (just like toddlers and terrible twos). That, and they just want to experiment with lying. So like Jen's last idea, you show them that by lying, they have lost your trust. Now you have to monitor them very closely and she should hate that.

Also just wanna offer some sympathy, Kristie. I know it can't be easy for you right now, suddenly having a 9 year old to manage, and one who is testing you. Hang in there. Don't let it ruin the holiday. I wouldn't do anything else with the Christmas presents if I were you, just cuz that will really put a damper on the whole holiday for everybody. You're doing a great job with all the change right now, just keep it up. She'll come around :) 

J3nnif3r --- 15 years ago -

Good point about Christmas Rachel. After some thought... you should give her back the one you took away, and then smile tonight as you follow her into the bathroom and when she looks at you funny just wink and say "I'm only here to supervise!" :) 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

Oh and then, since I think her behavior is mostly about control, once she starts to do it on her own again and things settle down, maybe you guys can think of one or two kinda "big" things to give her responsibility for. Do it in a really positive way, like since you're getting so grown we think you can handle....
Make it something not just a chore, but something that she will think it kind of grown up or important. Then give her a chance to do it. And of course a lot of praise when she does.

You have to deal with this bad behavior now, but she's acting out because she needs more of something, so once things are kinda calm, try to give her more of whatever thing she is missing, in a good way. Hope that makes sense. 

badstreetusa --- 15 years ago -

I've got an 8 yr old who will never lie to me again.

Good luck with that, that's what every parent "hopes" for... 

J3nnif3r --- 15 years ago -

You don't know my Stevie ;)

She's seriously the kid who really believes that mommy has a 7th sense... eyes in the back of her head... and knows all (like Santa, or God.) Out of fear, she wouldn't lie to me. 

badstreetusa --- 15 years ago -

Lmao! 

J3nnif3r --- 15 years ago -

you know... after that one spanking, I haven't had to spank her again... (it's been about 2 years.)

My husband and I went outside one afternoon to take the kids out to play. We walked around the side of our building, and I noticed someone had written "BUTTHEAD" on the side of the building in sidewalk chalk. Well, that's a term we frequently kid around with at home... not to mention it was totally her handwriting.

I was already contemplating punishment for lying when I asked her if she did it. You can't imagine my SHOCK when she told me "yes, I did it." I was like :o :o :o

I promised her always that her punishment for telling the truth would be far better than if she lied. So when she said she did it I simply said "ok, well please go upstairs and get something to wipe it off with." And that was it. 

Kristie --- 15 years ago -

We do plan on giving her present back. It wasn't a great one that was taken away anyways so she wouldn't mind if she actually knew what it was. I do hate that is happened on Christmas eve of all days because I feel bad that she doesn't get to do the fun Christmas stuff because it's the holliday but I also think she did do it to herself. She already got into trouble for it once, she should know she can't get away with it again. I'm not sure what to do. Any other time of the year she would be grounded for more than a day but since tomorrow is Christmas it's hard to decide. I will be watching her brush for now on until I know she will do it without me there. She gets to learn how to do her own laundry next week too. I'm not too sure what control I can give her. I don't know what she can handle. She keeps asking for a key to the house, not sure why, but I kinda laughed at her. She's already lost a glove and her binder for school and I'm not sure I can trust her with a key to the house. She's learned so much since she's been here already.
She never did chores before she came here and now she has them almost everry day but she also gets to do things for soing them. She chose to do basketball and Girl Scouts so thats what she gets to do.
I'm not liking being the mom to a 9yr old right now. I wish her own mom was more of a mom. 

Kristie --- 15 years ago -

And Jason has spanked her before and it doesn't seem to phase her. She has had to write sentences and it worked for a while but it seemed to stop after a while. I think all we really have left is grounding. 

Jaymee --- 15 years ago -

I wouldn't make a big deal out of it. I would just up my supervision. Just say if I can't trust you to do it on your own then I'll insure that it gets done. And if you really wanted to make the point I would brush them for her for about a week and make it a long and drawn out process.
* If this is the only thing she is lying about. If she is lying about several other things that would change my opinion. 

Jaymee --- 15 years ago -

I have found the less I care about the outcome the more they do. I try and make it their problem as much as possible. It's no skin off my back if I have to go in and brush your teeth no biggie for me and just do it like it is another simple task. No comments no lectures. Just shrug your shoulder and say this is just what happens when you don't do it yourself. 

RoxAnne --- 15 years ago -

I babysat/raised my nieces and ran into a similar issue. My niece would I guess just stand in the shower...not sure what she did all that time in there....but she would get out and her hair was dry so I knew she wasnt washing it. I would make her get back in the shower to wash it. Of course she would get out and it would be half wet...so I would make her get a towel shampoo and conditioner and I washed her hair in the sink. She HATED me for it. She was forever
mad at me. But after the same process a couple times she finally realized it was so much quiker to do it herself the first time. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

Oh yeah.. and if push comes to shove, brush her teeth FOR her. My daughter hates that lol

make sure to check them too, because kids really don't do a great job of brushing --or get her a sonicare or something similar that has a built in timer idk....something

take her TO the dentist, has she had a checkup? maybe there is something wrong like someone mentioned....or maybe she is afraid of the dentist

not all kids are afraid of the dentist

and not all kids who take poor care of their teeth will end up with cavities, nor will all kids that brush really well NOT end up with any.......that part is the luck of the draw....

maybe she hates the toothpaste? sounds silly but my hubby and son are pretty picky about the toothpaste since the flavor lingers.....

I'm not liking being the mom to a 9yr old right now. I wish her own mom was more of a mom.

I do too==I am sure she does also....... being a kid that age and ending up in a situation where you get tossed around has to suck.........and it has to be really hard on you guys too......one thing that I found when we had 'new kids' was that I kept telling them over and over 'i am not going to stop loving you or caring for you no matter how hard you try to MAKE ME'.....maybe she will give up and just stop trying to be oppositional 

J3nnif3r --- 15 years ago -

Agreed RoxAnne.

I don't really believe in grounding. I tried it with my 8 yr old, and she's smart enough to realize that while it's unbearable having to wait things out... they eventually grounding is over and it didn't solve anything to begin with. (besides, I'd prefer my annoying children be out on the playground than under my feet!)

For you Kristie... start from the ground up. I don't know if you have other children... but if you do, treat your SD as you would them. So what if you have to revert back to age 4 in order to get your point across... the sooner she learns that you're a PARENT and not just a stepmother, the better ya know? 

Kristie --- 15 years ago -

Thanks for the advice everyone! Jason loves the idea of brushing her teeth for her so he will be doing that for the next week. Yes, we do need to make her a dentist so that will be done Monday, I hope. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

make her floss too (I am the oral care weirdo) 

badstreetusa --- 15 years ago -

And also, if they (kids) don't like the traditional floss, use "Plackers" (sp?) the little plastic flosser thingys...my kids like those because they are easier to handle. Always keep a bag handy, car, home, work, etc. Love those things! 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

the plackers are great, but not for use all the time if you can help it..........best to use real floss on them (mom or dad helping cuz it is hard) regularly.....

we carry those things around too, love them 

Kristie --- 15 years ago -

I have to have them in my car. I hate eating and not having them with me. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Spang Underground