Spang Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Spang bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent in Spang courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Spangdahlem PT testing

who's talking here?

RoxAnne 4
Rachel 9
Renee 9
Kayla 6
melissaa 1
KMC 3
Kristen 11
Jaymee 1
Girl from the south 1
Aaron 3
J3nnif3r 9
badstreetusa 15
Jason 3
Kristie 4
Amy 1
June 1
CMMG 1
dodger 6

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

Are they really going to kick that many people out? It was a 75% fail rate? 

June --- 16 years ago -

No, it's not that high. Our commander quoted 18% basewide. And less than that AF wide. Yes, more are failing but tons are still passing. I think people just hear so much about failures because they speak the loudest LOL 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

try over 50% basewide... (this coming directly from the people who test us.) 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

wow 

Renee --- 16 years ago -

June, maybe he was saying 80, not 18... LOL! I had also heard that the fail rates were pretty high. I truly believe though, that before they start kicking people out, they need to re-think their PT test. It just isn't a good program. 

Amy --- 16 years ago -

According to my husbands commander, fail rate for his squadron was %68 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

I think the inclusion of a body composition element on the pt test is foolish. 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

Yeah, if a person can perform whatever tasks, why does their height/weight ratio matter? Maybe it would be more useful to take into account some lab workups, like cholesterol or something :) 

Renee --- 16 years ago -

I think it is great that they are expecting people to be more fit, but I agree with Jason that the body composition element of the test just doesn't make sense. You have guys with pot bellies who measure small around their "waist" because it falls under their overhanging spare tire, then there are people like my hubs, who are just built large, who are fit but who have trouble with the waist measurment simply because of their size. Just doesn't add up. 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

I do see the need for some type of action/regulation- some of the active duty I see are just ridiculously out of shape. It's a part of their job, after all. I mean, a lot of professions have continuing requirements and evaluations that must be met at certain intervals. Maybe taking fast food joints off of bases would be a good start.
These strict PT fail consequences just treat the result of the problem, not the problem itself. There should be intervention earlier. 

Kayla --- 16 years ago -

I agree that the body composition is silly in some respects. I think there is a lot of intervention (My husband is a UFMP, and runs conducts all tests at Buchel). I'm not sure about those at Spang, but for those who are on the edge, there is mock testing, and fitness training available. I think some of it is a matter of personal responsibility and getting out and doing some real PT all year, instead of cramming right before a test and hoping to pass.
The other service PT tests are MUCH more stringent, and they don't seem to be having near the same issues as us. I know their mission is different in a lot of respects, but either way, it's part of the job.
I also think it's a way the higher ups found for reducing the force (which they are currently trying to do by a 30% margin a believe). I don't think it's necessarily right, but I think it's a way they found to get some out.
Stinks either way. 

badstreetusa --- 16 years ago -

It's laughable to think closing fast food restaurants on base will have a major factor in fitness. People can still go off base and it just boils down to self control. I know in order to stay fit I should not eat bk everyday. But, that doesn't mean i shouldn't have the option on base.

Lastly I call bs on all the percentages being thrown around. It just adds to the ever spinning rumor mill. 

Kayla --- 16 years ago -

I agree with your bs call-badstreet. Especially since everyone has something different. 

Kristie --- 16 years ago -

Most of the other branches do PT almost everyday... together. The AF just lets most squardons do it on their own and no one does it. I know a few SF that actually get to the gym regularly but if they work flight, they never go because there isn't anyone there to make sure they do.
It's sad that someone needs to make them, but thats the way it is. 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

What I seriously thought was unfair, was closing our chow hall down for reconstruction, without offering some other sort of healthy alternative for the airmen. YES - I know they can easily get to the commissary and shop for quick/easy/healthy lunch options there and "do it themselves." But when you look at the big picture, our airmen are like school-children who need to be parented. We give them a meal card and a chow hall, and this is where they're trained to graze. Take that away and surround them with Popeyes and BK and JR Rockers and Pizza Hut, well.... what do you expect?

No excuse, but still.

And ALL of the components of this new test are absolutely ridiculous to any of us with common sense. It's like playing the lottery... sure, you've got a chance of passing, but it's slim! Better guess your numbers right! 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

Hey, I didn't say closing fast food places would make a huge difference, but for some ppl, if it's not there, they won't eat it. They will pack a sandwich instead.
As far as
that doesn't mean i shouldn't have the option on base

no one needs that option. That is one of the major problems with the "obesity epidemic" in America now- we think fast food is an actual food option, something that we should eat, and feed to our families. Like, should I make chicken and broccoli tonight, reheat the leftover roast from yesterday and throw together a salad, or do BK? It should not be viewed as a viable meal option. It barely qualifies as food. Like Jen said, closing the dining fac, which is closer to real food, and providing no suitable substitute, was a bad move.

Disclaimer: yes, I occasionally eat fast food, and yes, I even give it to my family on occasion. But I still believe it's evil :) 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

**hugs** Rachel! You're so smart :D

I LOOOVE me some fast food... got majorly addicted when I was pregnant because, well, I was gonna get fat anyway, so why not?!

What stinks, is now I've got 5 months left of a 6 month time limit to get back in shape before my test rolls around :( SHAME ON ME AND MY WHOPPERS! 

Kristie --- 16 years ago -

J'nnifer, I was that way with Big Macs, I ate them every chance I got when I was pregnant. I still have about 5lbs on me that I'm too lazy to work off but it's ok with me. I need motivation to go to the gym, thats why I liked manditory PT, they made me go. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

hubby who is 43 now just went and had a full physical, the stress test thing when you do it with a heart monitor, all blood levels, etc.....and he came back fit, actually his cholesterol levels are better than guys in much better shape than others...and he eats BK at least 1x a week and the club 1x a week

my friend who is skinny and exercises every day has high cholesterol.....so a lot of it is genetics too on cholesterol and even high blood pressure

my hubby would have been on the program or kicked out if when he was in the standards are what they just changed them to....he is TALL.......6'4" and weighs usually around 215.......so that is reasonable for a guy over 40, but guess where it ALL IS? belly.....

and yeah, push ups, well, he has bursitis in his shoulder, the same one where he ruined his rotator cuff by loading weapons and working with heavy stuff

he said he totally would fail now, and that sucks, because when he was in he was the bomb, they would have lost a great troop.....

one of his friends used to pass all the time but spends 20 mins of each hour outside smoking..........so yeah, that is another pet peeve of mine.........you have to put in 60 mins but the other dude has to put in 40.........

ok rant off 

KMC --- 16 years ago -

I'm not really a huge fan of including body composition into the score, at least they way they have done it. I know several very fit and muscular guys who have issues with the waist measurement. For my husband's job, being strong is much more important than being having the ideal waist measurement. A caliper test would be a much better(but more time consuming) method to measure body composition. That being said, from working out at the gym on base there are a lot of un-fit people in the AF (not saying I am the picture of health or anything, but its not my job to be in decent shape). 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

J'nnifer your point about the dfac being closed is significant because many airmen now have very few healthy alternatives. I think the dfac could have done a better job offering healthy food though. 

KMC --- 16 years ago -

Is the food at dfac really that much better of an option... When my husband was eating at the chow hall at Andrews he was always complaining about how everything was either fried or drowned in butter. He's had the same issue when deployed... I'm sure its better than BK, but by how much I am not sure. We've discussed many times how it is ironic that the military expects you to be the picture of health, then makes it very hard to eat correctly. 

Kayla --- 16 years ago -

I agree closing down the DFAC has left people with more limited options. One thing about the DFAC doing a better job offering healthy food---they are on a 14 day mandatory cycle menu, and have specific recipe cards etc. and are pretty limited on how far they can stray from that.....

The new test is probably most definitely flawed (as are most things involving military), and it is more difficult, but I think there's a reason for that too. I think it's good to look at what factors are causing failure, but ultimately I still think it comes down to personal responsibility. People KNOW they have to pass it, so do whatever you have to to get through it... 

Kayla --- 16 years ago -

Then again, I'm not having to do the testing, so my perspective is different. 

Girl from the south --- 16 years ago -

Strangely, my hubby scored better on the new system than the old.
Granted they measured his waist 1" less than ever before....and he has had the same waist measurement since high school (dang it why couldn't I be that way!!) AND they said he weighed less than he did coming out of basic. So I think maybe there was some serious human error that helped him.

It would be VERY nice to have a few FAST healthy options that don't include an overcrowded commissary salad bar. Heavens can't someone GRILL some chicken without dousing it in butter and mayo???? 

Kayla --- 16 years ago -

The place from where they measure also changed with the new AFI Gina--it puts the waist a little higher I believe, either way, it's measured differently than previously, I believe, which may be way it measured smaller! But either way, go Damon!

And SERIOUSLY on the grilled chicken! I miss my Jason's Deli..... 

KMC --- 16 years ago -

Yeah, my husband actually does a bit better with the new system as well... he said that they made the max points waist measurement a little bit more lenient, so he does a bit better there than he used to. That is what usually keeps him from getting a perfect score. 

badstreetusa --- 16 years ago -

The place from where they measure also changed with the new AFI Gina--it puts the waist a little higher I believe, either way, it's measured differently than previously, I believe, which may be way it measured smaller!

Wrong, you all should read the AFI and stop adding to the rumor mill. 

badstreetusa --- 16 years ago -

And ALL of the components of this new test are absolutely ridiculous to any of us with common sense. It's like playing the lottery... sure, you've got a chance of passing, but it's slim! Better guess your numbers right!

Please...all the components are the same, they just added minimums and changed the point spread. The components, waist measurement, run, sit-ups, and push ups are the same. To make such a broad statement that passing is "slim" shows how out of touch you are with reality in regards to the actual fitness test stats...you are just flat-out wrong. 

badstreetusa --- 16 years ago -

Agree that the DFAC being closed is BS...however...all this ranting about fast food...what is keeping those folks affected going to the commissary and eating better and cheaper (in some cases) than BK and Popeye's? 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Spang Underground