Spang Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Spang bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent in Spang courtesy of Military Real Estate!

disability

who's talking here?

Rachel 3
Renee 3
Mom of 1 4
Kayla 1
Kristen 4
LaurenB 1
badstreetusa 2
Jason 4
Mary 1
chang! 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Mom of 1 --- 16 years ago -

Can someone give me some information about disability? We know people that are on disability and one is still working a full time job and the other is going to school full time. The one that is working full time is apparently getting disability from the federal government and therefore is still allowed to work. Isn't the point of disability to provide money for those that can't work due to a disability. The used to be in the military and was discharged with 30% disability and gets 100% from the state, but the government is still paying for him to go to school. I don't see the point of paying for his schooling when he'll never be able to use any degree he gets. Can someone please explain why we were paying taxes for these people to get free money? 

Kayla --- 16 years ago -

Is the disability from the military--or government disability?
This is just from personal experience, but there are different TYPES Of disability they may not allow you to do one job, but could still do another. My brother had a stroke while in the Army and was medically discharged with 80% disability. He will never again be able to do any type of job that he had in the military and his options for the type of job he CAN do is VERY limited. He served his time, so still get his G.I.Bill and his schooling paid for. That's HIS right to that benefit. He will hopefully eventually become a teacher (He was MPI and SWAT in the military), but that doesn't mean his life still won't be without MANY different disabilities and make his life (and job), that much more challenging. I think although he will eventually be paid for a job, he is absolutely entitled to the medical disability from the military, because he was forced out of the Army (he would have been more than a lifer), and had his life RADICALLY changed which is causing many issues in his readjustment as well.

I do agree there are some people who take advantage of disability etc. but I think it really depends on the case and if its military disability etc. 

badstreetusa --- 16 years ago -

It does depend on the type of disability. I know several folks that are getting 100 percent disability but are still able to work certain jobs. Just worry about yourself and your family issues and don't worry over other folks you can't control. 

LaurenB --- 16 years ago -

It definitely depends on the degree of disability and whether you are talking military disabled or just state disabled. Both have different percentage levels of disability, which determines what you can do as far as work and school.

I personally would rather have my taxes going to someone who is bettering their self with education rather than other people that "abuse" the system. Why do you think he may never get to use his degree? There are certain jobs you can work being on disability, you just can't make over a certain amount a month. 

Mary --- 16 years ago -

so just because somebody has a disablility he should not get an education? What world are we living in?
I know somebody who sits in a wheelchair since birth, can´t really do anything himself, needs 24/7 care and help, he now is in his late 30s, a successful lawyer and lobbiest for people with disablities. I am sure that nobody who sees him the first time would expect him to be a lawyer, so please don´t make assupmtions about peoples abilities. 

Mom of 1 --- 16 years ago -

I'm not judging them. I'm just trying to figure out the reason for them getting the disability. The one that is going to start getting 100% disability was in the military until he was in an accident and messed up his jaw. He was discharged from the military about 15 years ago and just recently went in complaining of headaches so they are offering him disability, but he's still able to keep his job. He is a heavy equiptment operator so if the headaches are causing you to get disability wouldn't you also have to rethink on the job safety?

The one that is going to school has said he'll never be able to get a job. He's been through 3 degrees now and when it comes to on the job training he tells them he can't do it. When he was in the military, they offered his a desk job, but either him or his doctors decided he couldn't do that either. He is not using the GI bill for his schooling. The state is paying for it. Again I'm not trying to judge them. I'm trying to figure out what the reason is for cases like these. Really I'm just using these two people as examples. 

badstreetusa --- 16 years ago -

What is wrong with people taking advantage of lawful programs that are in place? 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

You are thinking about the whole thing wrong. It's kinda like workmans compnsation. When you join the military you are a healthy human being. Because of the nature of the work it is possible that you may suffer a permanent injury or disability. It might not necessarily be something that keeps you from working it could simply be something that affects ur quality of life.

For instance. You join the af serve honorably and suddenly your knees are injured in a training accident. You get a knee surgery or two but there is some pain from time to time and you can never run again. Long walks are out of the question. Since your quality of life has been affected (for the rest of your life) you are compensated.

Should tax dollars pay for this? Hell yes. These people are sacrificing their body to work as part of the well oiled machine that is the military. They don't get paid well, their family life suffers, mostly their are crapped on on a regular basis. Most who will go to combat will be forever traumatized by the image of friends dying or their victims brains running down a wall. The only good thing they have going for them is the knowledge that if they lose their arm (or mind) giving their sacrifice for their country, they will be compensated for their loss. It's the least that the taxpayers of our country can do.

You might think a jaw injury is a petty thing to get compensation (you might not) but it's part of his comprehensive benefits package. You (or your husband is you are a dependent spouse) will appreciate the comprehensive benefits package one day. Maybe your husband is a crew chief and by the time he gets out he has some indications of hearing loss and tendinitis in his elbow. Maybe your husband will suffer a blow on the head while in the line of duty. You will then understand the sacrifice to quality of life when he wakes up in the middle of the night with headaches.

I promise you that at some point you or someone you know will take advantage of the opportunities provided by the va. That's what they are there for, to be used.

Can you put a price on your leg? Your hand? If you had very bad headaches associated with an injury how much would you pay to not have them? I used to spend a lot of time at va hospitals and not everyone loses a leg or an arm. One guy I know spent 20 years trying to get veterans compensation for his PTSD from nam. It took 20 years. Now days peoplecan get it in a year but this is only a recent event. Up until 3 years ago there were people who had waited years for their claim to be processed. 

Renee --- 16 years ago -

Good points Jason. My husband, for instance, has damaged his knees climbing towers for the AF. It is a very common problem in his line of work, and it was something they warned the recruits about in Tech. school, not that they were given a choice - it was something along the lines of, "You are going to ruin your knees climbing these towers, but hey, the military will compensate you when you get out." My husband's knees sound like popcorn is popping every time he does a squat for his PT tests. They swell, they get really sore from the mandatory runs, regular work days, etc. It isn't going to keep him from being able to work once he gets out, but it will cause him problems for the rest of his life, he will eventually have to have double knee replacements, and as he gets older have to deal with arthritis pain etc. He will be receiving military disability compenasation while continuing to work, and imho, he deserves it. 

Mom of 1 --- 16 years ago -

Jason-Thank you for the information. It makes more sense when you put it that way. In the civilian world, if you are injured on the job, don't you usually just recieve a one time payout from workmen's compensation? So its more of a military benefit, not something that's always offered to people who are injured on the job?

Renee-So does everyone in your husband's career field get compensated when they get out no matter if they are having problems or not...or is it one of those if you don't have problems now, you can come back when you do things? Will your husband have to retire with the military (or get medically discharged) to recieve those benefits or can he get that even if he finishs his 4 years and gets out? 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

good luck getting the benefits, and it is not a payment amount unless you get more thant 60% or some amount, it is just a reduction in how much of your pay gets taxed or something

in Cali, you can get disability even if you are pregnant, you considered disabled during part of it........that comes from the state or something

then there is federal (no VA) disability that some people get........

so it really depends on what kind of disability you are receiving in civ world because there are a few kinds...... 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

If you are injured in the military and that injury is something that will cause problems then you are entitled to Veterans Compensation. In the past there was a tremendous amount of red tape a person would have to walk through to get VA benefits. With so many soldiers returning from happy land with medical and psychological problems the VA faced a massive backlog (combined with serious cuts during the Bush presidency). About a year and a half ago the new commander of the VA announced that all claims would be processed within 1 year. Claims must still go through an extensive review process but it is easier than ever for Veterans to receive compensation for injuries.

Kristen, even if you only rate 10% compensation you still receive a cash payment from the VA (may be different if you are still active duty). Furthermore all VA compensation is tax free.

You can receive VA compensation irregardless of any other disability payments you receive from state agencies. I know that some people who are rated 100% who receive Social Security Disability payments as well as their VA compensation.

Mom of 1- you can receive a one time payout from worker comp but you can also receive a monthly payment similar to a paycheck. For instance if you are a US civilian contractor here in Germany and you are badly injured on the job you can receive a one time payment. If there is no other job in your field you can work anymore you can receive pay checks as if you were still working for the company. It's insurance. Some people pay for it for their whole lives and never need it, some people work for 2 days and get tragically injured. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

funny, hubby talked to VA 3 months ago she said it had to be over at least 50% before it would be CASH PAYMENT...that what it does is reduce your taxable retirement income, that is all

I guess better argue you on it, who is your VA contact? I will have him call them.

figures, the 3 different answers from 3 different people

also, hubby's brother gets no cash payment either and has 30% 

Mom of 1 --- 16 years ago -

Does anyone know if its true that if you are head of household and are recieving 100% disability, each member of your family recieves $1000/month. If you have 5 people in your family, that's $5000 a month. Do you know any families that make $5000/month? 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

I do not know, and I would not ever even have the guts to ask someone who was unfortunate enough to be 100% disabled 'do you make $5000 a month because you are disabled...... and I hope we never find out :( the hard way 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

Are you talking about military?

http://www.military.com/benefits/veteran-benefits/va-compensation-tables#BM03 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

Kristen, the same table does show a rate for 10%, 20% and 30%... 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

This is pretty interesting, too:

http://www.vfvc.net/pages/va_disability_rating_criteria.htm

According to this, the disability must be recorded by a doctor before discharge, except for PTSD.

Momof1, it also talks about what receiving 100% disability means, and how a person can still work, and what type of job they can hold (toward the end). 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

This is from the VA rate table http://www.vba.va.gov/bln/21/Rates/comp01.htm

100% with no spouse or children $2673

100% with spouse and 5 children $2932 + $75 for each extra child (300) = $3232

I do not know anyone making $5000 a month from Veterans Benefits and if someone was telling you that they are taking you for a ride.

I do on the other hand know quite a few families that make $5000 a month. Every Captain you know in the military makes about that much. Most Senior and Cheifs make almost that much. There are many civilian families who make $5000 a month. A husband and wife making 16$ an hour each could make that. According to the census bureau the average median family income is $50000/year. 

Renee --- 16 years ago -

Mom of 1 - No, not everyone gets compensated. Some do manage to make it through knees intact, but there is about an 85% rate of permanent stress injury. It is not something you can just bring up once you get out. It has to be documented over time in your medical records and show a definite progression. My husband will be retiring from the AF, and when one retires or separates, one is required to see a VA representative, who helps that individual go over his/her VA benefits, including disability. (FYI:The AF actually contracts out most antenna work now, so the hubby's job field got merged with cable maintenance, unfortunately the damage was already done after 10 years of climbing 300 ft. towers.) 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

Renee- Make sure your husband goes to the doctor for his exit physical, if there is nothing documented at the exit physical he can have complications in getting his VA claim approved. Also, men tend to be kind of macho about pain so they wont complain much but make sure to tell him to be very honest with the doctor. 

Renee --- 16 years ago -

Thanks Jason. I'll pass that on... he is definitely "macho" about his pain. Sucks it up and rarely complains, but I know it's hurting when he groans getting out of bed in the morning. He actually went to have it looked at at Landstuhl a while ago. They didn't do any x-rays, MRI, nothing, just wiggled his knee around a bit and basically said, "suck it up until they don't work anymore". He felt pretty bad given that there were guys there with NO knees. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

[i]Kristen, the same table does show a rate for 10%, 20% and 30%...[/i]

glad it came up here then, father in law and brother in law are both being 'ripped' off really then........I am sending them both an email

it will be years before hubby's status is determined so who knows what will happen by then....but this is good documentation for him to use for proof if they try to give him the shaft

THANK YOU

I never looked it up, the VA stuff is his 'deal' but he was going on what his retired Vet dad told him and his brother who has partial disability. 

chang! --- 16 years ago -

Just because you are rated through the VA for a condition doesn't mean that you automatically get money each month for it. The VA somehow determines what conditions are compensable and what conditions aren't. I have no clue how they figure this out, but some how they do. I have a rating through the VA, some which I get a monthly compensation for and others that I don't. If you don't get a monthly compensation for them, but they are rated, this means that you are eligible for medical care with the VA for these items. The compensable issues are also eligible to be cared for at the VA.

Also, you can obtain a rating without the issue ever being documented in your records. It will be harder to prove, but it can be done. One of my ratings is for a concern that isn't documented in any of my medical records. Long story as to why, but it was never documented. The VA did find the issue valid and that it was service related.

Another thing that might help for those that are getting ready to retire. If an issue is combat related, then it is in the best interest of the military member to get this documented in the medical records. Combat related injuries are dealt with differently I believe and this may increase bennies. I know that it helps dependents and widows also.

Kristen - There is a new thing that started a few years ago that is called concurrent receipt. It's were the government is starting to phase out the combining of a VA disability check and the retirement check. If you think about it, vets are getting ripped off. Having a disability through the VA and retiring are two different things. If someone serves their country and gets hurt in the process, why shouldn't they be entitled to both checks? They more than earned it. Someone in Congress finally got smart and realized that vets were entitled to both checks. Slowly but surely they are separating the two checks and soon (not sure when or if they are at the point now)it will be that retirees will get a separate deposit for the two instead of the disability check being tax free within their retirement check.

For those of you interested, here's a link to the VA booklet. I believe they update it every year. It talks about the AD members benefits and also what spouses or surviving spouses are entitled to.
http://www1.va.gov/opa/publications/benefits_book.asp 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Spang Underground