Spang Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Spang bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent in Spang courtesy of Military Real Estate!

bottle bombs

who's talking here?

Rachel 1
Renee 1
Kayla 3
Kristen 6
Aaron 3
Jason 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

http://www.snopes.com/crime/warnings/bottlebomb.asp 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

The 'toxic gas' is hydrogen not really harmful. The drain may cause some irritation but nothing that cannot be fixed with water. I've made them before with dry ice and a small amount of water. They aren't likely to sever fingers. The bottle explodes because the pressure inside increases until there is a critical failure in the bottle. 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

But you can get a chemical burn/irritation from the toxic chemicals in the Drano or whatever. Especially bad in the face or eyes, and especially for a child. 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

Yes that's the part that is an irritant, but 2nd and 3rd degree burns are extreme. It's also got to be diluted with water it cannot be pure draino. 

Aaron --- 16 years ago -

@Jason; So are you saying the article is inaccurate or are you saying that 1st degree burns aren't a big deal?
It doesn't sound pleasant to me either way and if some jackass put one of these in my yard and my kid picked it up, chances are I'd shove one up that person's @$$.
From this video, it looks like it could do as much damage as a pot of boiling water and the pressure blast could cause several types of injuries. Check out the video below.
 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

It seems to me also to be a pretty big deal. That was kind of why I posted it. I hope no one ever finds one of these. 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

Aluminum does not usually corrode (oxidized) under normal circumstances. It requires a weak acid to help it this reaction. While something as weak as lemon juice will work, drano (hydrochloric acid) will work very quickly.

The oxidation process happens like this. An acid (and water) combines with the aluminum. The oxygen is removed from the water by the acid and combined with the aluminum leaving 2 hydrogen atoms. As the reaction continues more and more hydrogen gas builds up. The pressure of the gas increases until the bottle can no longer withstand the stress and it breaks, rapidly releasing the built up gas. Hydrogen is not toxic. The hydrochloric acid in drano isn't necessarily good for you but I don't think it will give you 2nd and 3rd degree chemical burns like the article says.

The reaction is not exothermic, it does not release heat. Of course if you had a heat source available on the outside of the device such as a burning stick, that would create a very nice fire ball since hydrogen gas and heat are a flammable combination.

Could you be hurt if you grabbed one of these things sitting on your lawn? Sure. If you are in the habit of picking up strange bottles with bubbling liquid in them then you should be very concerned. You don't have to worry about the person getting very far away though because it doesn't take long for this device to go off.

Nobody is going to find any of these in their lawn Kristen, don't worry about it. 

Kayla --- 16 years ago -

Probably not here, but I wouldn't be so sure you wouldn't find one. If you notice in watching many of the videos, these are kids experimenting with these things. I'm not worried about MY kids doing this, but with other kids, you really can never be too sure....just sayin. 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

I understand the concern Kayla. The first bottle bomb I learned to make was with dry ice and water. You could control how long it took for the device to go off by how much water you used and you could give them a delay of almost 20 minutes (accuracy in timing is impossible).

These 'works' bombs work very quickly. For you to walk out of your house and pick up one you would probably have seen the kid put it on your lawn in the first place. Maybe you would find debris from one, but I doubt it.

Nobody is going to put one on your lawn with the intention of hurting you. There isn't much chance they can do it without being seen, and it is an explosive device, it's not quite the same punishment as lighting a bag of poop on your doorstep. 

Aaron --- 16 years ago -

Sorry Kristin, I guess you and I were wrong. These things are completely safe! And to celebrate the chemistry lesson I just learned, I'm going to go drink a bottle of drano since it is apparently harmless. Then to cap off the night, I'm going to let one of these things blast off in my face. They seem safe enough, it should have no effect. On second thought, I'll just pour the drano straight into my eyes because I'm that confident in Jason's science. I'll give one to each of my kids too! Shake it up, kids and get ready for not 2nd and 3rd degree burns. 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

Perhaps you could be more irrational and extreme. It's drano, of course it'll hurt your eyes, and you probably don't want it on your skin for too long, though it won't cause 2nd or 3rd degree burns (as said in the article). If you drink it it's gonna make you feel pretty bad (poison control recommends drinking milk and not inducing vomiting).

Is it reasonable that people are going to put them on you lawn with the intent of hurting you? No. The device activates too quickly. Sure it's possible, it's possible someone could park a car in front of your house and detonate a high order explosive, but neither aren't likely.

Take a chemistry class, you will learn a great deal. The chemical reaction in in the bottle is similar to a reaction used to launch some rockets. They use the hydrogen byproduct as a fuel.

Try taking a dose of rational thought with your daily vitamins. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

Look, I rarely post things I get via email and this one concerned me. I am not really afraid of finding one in the yard, I live off base and the kids are destructo freaks here but don't even know if they have Drano.

This is good info if you have friends stateside, where it IS happening, and kids are mean, they want to hurt people sometimes. It obviously has happened, and hurt people. There are kids that have been injured by it.

Another side of this is that it is a good idea to make sure to know about these because if YOUR kids (anyone's including mine) start taking two liters and drano and my foil, I am clued in. 

Kayla --- 16 years ago -

My thoughts exactly Kristen. In the states, it wouldn't surprise me AT ALL, for someone to leave something that takes approx. 2 minutes to go off in a yard of another kid they don't like. And while I do my best to see the good everywhere, sometimes we just have to be honest with what the world is looking like.

I couldn't agree more Kristen, and kudos for getting the word out and educating people, regardless of whether everyone agrees. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

Heck, kids may start making them here. My kid could be one of them. I am strange I pay attention to things that may or may not be significant but if my drano or foil is missing I am going to ask around, that is for sure. I was a 'good kid' but I still did bad things sometimes. 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

These aren't devices to hurt people. Injury can certainly result from handling one but that is more likely to happen to the person who made it. You said there are people ( other than the manufacturer) who are being hurt by these. Who? You said there are kids that havebeen injured by it, what kids?

As far as finding some missing from your house....it would be very exciting to have a budding young chemist in the house. While crude devices like the works bomb can be made, there are many beneficial things you can make with drano and aluminum. You can produce hydrogen gas, a very exciting and common gas. You can use the aluminum and acid to make a battery. Yep, when I took chemistry in colllege we did experiments converting aluminum cans in to electrical energy with the ultimate goal of powering a heater. There are lots of good uses for aluminum and drano. 

Aaron --- 16 years ago -

Oh, YES! My budding, young chemist son stole my tinfoil and drain cleaner and blasted some poor kid's hand into a nub. "Sorry you're in prison, Timmy, but good news is you won first prize in the science fair!"
This thread has become comical in so many ways.
Look, science is awesome and I commend the people who can make that connection. I, as Jason has pointed out, am not smart enough to determine the difference between a budding young chemist and a punk kid tossing works bombs in several peoples' yards and hoping for a big bang. But if the possibility exists of my wife, my kid, my dog or any innocent person being harmed from it (whether a plastic cut, a burst eardrum, an eye full of chemicals, etc) then it's probably not a good idea for someone to be making them under non-controllable circumstances.
Maybe it was harmless fun, but an ignorant act, nonetheless.
Jason, nobody is attacking your love of drano or it's effects on shiny things. She just wanted to get the message out there in case you saw a swollen bottle or whatever. Plus the article was interesting.
Maybe you are smarter than me-in fact, I can almost guarantee it-but if you think that these kids in the videos are studying ways to make hydrogen, then maybe you need to smarten up...and come on over, I'm pouring the shots of drano as we speak! 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

As far as finding some missing from your house....it would be very exciting to have a budding young chemist in the house.

come on, you are kidding, right? 

Renee --- 16 years ago -

I have a nephew that I can easily imagine making one of these. He would never even think about the fact that he could hurt someone, he'd be in it for the cool factor. He's inquisitive and likes to mess with things. I think most kids who might make something like this probably wouldn't think about the possible consequences, because that is just how kids are. I think it is good to know about, and have the opportunity to pre-empt a problem if you ever were to come across one, or find your kids collecting drano and foil, though I think it would be unlikely. Then again, lots of people are hurt by unlikely things happening all the time. And Kristen, with your neighbors being what they are, it's probably a good thing to be aware of! 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

Do what you do with guns. Instead of locking them away you teach your kids how to use one properly and how to treat it with respect. If your kid wants to try a science experiment, join in. Instead of saying 'no you can't do that you'll hurt yourself' find a way to do it so it can be safe and fun.

Kids will try things like this if they want to. Either you can be there tto help them be safe or you can let them figure it out for themselves. 

Kayla --- 16 years ago -

We had guns in our house in the states, and while my husband absolutely taught my oldest how to respect it and what it was, you can also absolutely believe we had them locked away. It's about awareness and responsibility.

Like Renee said, being inquisitive is great, but kids do things all the time without thinking of the consequences. I'm curious if you have kids of your own Jason? Coming from a mother, and from someone who worked with kids ranging from age 7-18 for multiple years, this kind of thing is far more common than you'd ever imagine, yes, even with intentions of hurting other kids.

Like I said before, awareness and responsibility. All there is to it. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

I have had boys in my house in the age range of age of -0- to 22. Not every kid, good or bad, comes and asks mom and dad when they want try to experiment with something they think is 'cool' or their friends tell them is cool and safe. I think that parents are best to be aware of things that WE have never even thought of.

Example, my liquor is missing, I would take notice. Some foil missing, I may or may not because who would think of foil to be dangerous?

Heck, watch the Little House on the Prairie episode when Carl lit off a firework mess in the barn. Kids do stuff that is bad or even dangerous, I know that, but I would rather prevent it. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Spang Underground