Spang Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Spang bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent in Spang courtesy of Military Real Estate!

parenting and money question

who's talking here?

Rachel 1
Renee 1
Kristen 3
Jason 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

If you have older kids, or ARE an older child........here is a question for you

Let's just say there are several kids, adult children, on their own.

Some need money on a pretty regular basis. Some do not and never ask for a dime, BUT could always use an extra few bucks.

Let's just say as a parent you decide to send one some cash, should you send some to the others also even though they did not ask for it, or do not even need it?

What my dilemma is here is why is the one who has been responsible any less deserving of a bonus?

It is kind of like the mortgage bailouts, credit card stuff, etc.....if you screw up, people throw money at you, but if you have planned well, lived without or worked WAY more than you needed to just go get ahead or safeguard yourself.......instead of just doing the bare minimums to get by....why are you not entitled to the free handout?

Thoughts?

ETA we have three kids that are between 21-24 and one needs money pretty regularly but rarely asks......and it is not out of being irresponsible.....the other two never ask, but thinking that maybe we should send them $$ more often than just birthdays and stuff? 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

Kristen, I think different "kids" need different things at different times, if that makes sense. We have had this issue in our family before. My mom will try really hard to make all money even between my siblings and I, but I think it's kinda silly. We don't all need it, so it doesn't matter.
I would suggest helping who needs to be helped, however that is. The others may have a time of need sometime, so save your $$ until then :)

The bailout stuff drives my crazy, too, by the way! Do what you are supposed to, pay your bills, and your reward is...nothing. I guess a feeling of pride in being responsible. But I still have to pay my mortgage! 

Renee --- 16 years ago -

That's a tough one Kristen! I tend to agree with Rachel's take on it. My mom and dad have bailed out siblings now and again, and given us help a couple of times when we needed it when we were younger and less responsible. They never worried about making it even. They always just gave what they could when they could, when it was needed. None of us ever felt as if it was unfair. So, I would have to second Rachel - save it and offer it when and if it is needed. Another option might be that, if you give a certain amount to one, and you want to give to all, then maybe put an equal amount into a high interest savings account for the others. It would earn interest, which would, over time, act as a reward for their being responsible and not needing a bailout! 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

Make sense, I just know they could use it, but don't *need it*. Sometimes getting a little gift is nice BUT don't want to start a bad trend.......

I also wonder sometimes if they will even ask when they do need it. Hard to say. None of them really asks, one just 'hints' more than the others. LOL 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

What a tough question. I'm a big fan of the school of thought that says 'the best lessons in life have a bitter taste.' If they need money why don't you help them get a loan, perhaps cosigning or putting up the money you were going to give as security on a loan. You will help them understand financial responsibility and help them improve their credit rating. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

I do have to say they have paid me back when it is a loan. I agree, the lessons are best learned the hard way and they are REALLY good about not asking.

Most of the time we just give it to them because they have all ALWAYS worked, done the best they could. One of the kiddos is in Job Corps and their income is like $23 a week so.......well you know......that is impossible to live on.

Even my little brother has paid me back when we loaned him money, that is a good thing.

I just kind of feel badly that we seem to be helping one out regularly.......like maybe we should just send something to the others. I think it opened my eyes when I realized how much of my dad's family mooches off of him (adult --like 40 and older siblings of mine and step siblings) and realized that our kiddos are so good about not being mooches.

I also wonder if the ones who don't 'need' gifts or loans really do but are too proud to ask. Hmm. 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

If they are hungry enough they'll ask for money. Otherwise it sounds like they are doing ok. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Spang Underground