Spang Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Spang bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent in Spang courtesy of Remilitary.com!

different bank rates

who's talking here?

Rachel 1
Kristen 3
Jason 1
Spangalang 1
Jeremiah 1
heather 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

heather --- 16 years ago -

has anyone noticed how we get the lowest exchange on base? why? i do nearly all my shopping off base but when i go to the bank on base i get a less rate. (ex. today's current rate is .82 on xe website but i got .78 on base) it is furious knowing i am getting cheated more by the bank on base. i know each bank sets their own rates according to the daily rate so they can earn their percentage (that's how it was explained from my bank back in the states) but it is so upsetting to get screwed on base. so not only do i get cheated when i pay my rent (over 60 american this past 1st) but they charge to pay your bills too(sure only a dollar but they already took over 60). i went to another bank and asked the amount i would have gotten charged on the 1st for my particuliar amount and it was way less. maybe i should not pay thru the bank and withdrawl the amount from another bank on base.....but wait.....there are atm fees and visa intl fees for not using the bank on base......so frustrating! anyone know a better idea???? 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

Well, I know a few people who have opened accounts at German banks off-base. Then they pay their bills through that, and get euro at the better rate. I think Kristen has a German bank account and can give you more info... USAA charges a 1% foreign transaction fee to get euro out of an off-base ATM. Depending on the exchange rate, it is often still better than on base because of the exchange rate thing you're talking about. If the off-base bank was offering a rate of .78, with the 1% fee, you would still be getting .79- a lot better than .82. Two problems, though, I don't know how to know the German bank's rate first to see how much better it is (it is always better than on base, but can vary how much). The other is that the rate on websites like xe are not available usually to an average person getting a smaller amount of actual cash. That is a best rate that a person might get when transferring around really large sums of money, usually all electronically, through various accounts. So we're getting screwed, but maybe not as much as it seems :) 

heather --- 16 years ago -

i got a bit lost. wouldn't .82 american to 1 euro be better than .79 american to 1 euro? we are new here and everyone was saying how much cheaper it is on base and how rates are better. i shopped one time at the commissary and feel it was outragious especially when i realized i got home and some of the meat was expired! thought they hired folks specifically for that? so started shopping off base and love it! way cheaper! i recently noticed the difference in rates and was flustered. sometimes i use my stateside account which is a visa as well (frost bank) and don't get charged atm fees or visa charge thru the atm since they don't charge them. i only get the 1% fee when using as credit at stores. hopefully kristen can enlighten me how to do the off bank banking so i can make the necessary adjustments. i hate losing more money than need be:P thanks for your help 

Jeremiah --- 16 years ago -

.79 to one is of course better than .82 to one if u want to GET euros. and most off-base bank employees speak english, so just feel free to go there and ask for your specific case, they can tell you all you need to know 

Spangalang --- 16 years ago -

The base's rate is a little slow in catching up because they have to sell off all their money that they had bought at the previous, lower rate. 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

I believe it is always cheaper to buy money in the nation that money is being used for. For instace if you were buying dollars with euros it would be cheaper in the us and not in Europe. Think of the military base as a little island of America in a host nation. It's not that they are trying to rip you off, it's what they are able to sell the euro at. 

heather --- 16 years ago -

thanks everyone for helping me understand how it works here. i am better equipped now to get what i need at the better rates and know why the bases rates are so different to offbase. thanks!! 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

I use a German bank account for rent and RWE. The only reason I even kept Community bank on base after finding out their fee, was that if TMobile/Telecom gives me trouble cancelling when we PCS I am keeping it JUST for that, and to use the ATM card to get cash and to write checks to people who only want local/on base checks. Our main banking is with USAA. I transfer money regularly from USAA via xe.com online to my German bank account and save a ton. Whenever I want cash I always got it off base at KSK or Volksbank even before having a German bank account, it is a MUCH better rate. Over the course of 3-5 years, I figure we will save probably $200 USD a month. We are not living paycheck to paycheck but I refuse to throw away money. That is $2400 a year. Really? that is......well heck, 3 weekend trips the way we travel. I am on a break between trips now but will try to check back in case you need more info. Rule of thumb is remember, after a certain amount of withdrawls USAA will also charge you ATM fees even when you use ATM at German ATM. Also, if you use credit a lot(we do for travel, carry less cash) there is ONE card that charges -0- transaction fees. That is all personal preference. You betcha we have it. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

I use a German bank account for rent and RWE. The only reason I even kept Community bank on base after finding out their fee, was that if TMobile/Telecom gives me trouble cancelling when we PCS I am keeping it JUST for that, and to use the ATM card to get cash and to write checks to people who only want local/on base checks. Our main banking is with USAA. I transfer money regularly from USAA via xe.com online to my German bank account and save a ton. Whenever I want cash I always got it off base at KSK or Volksbank even before having a German bank account, it is a MUCH better rate. Over the course of 3-5 years, I figure we will save probably $200 USD a month. We are not living paycheck to paycheck but I refuse to throw away money. That is $2400 a year. Really? that is......well heck, 3 weekend trips the way we travel. I am on a break between trips now but will try to check back in case you need more info. Rule of thumb is remember, after a certain amount of withdrawls USAA will also charge you ATM fees even when you use ATM at German ATM. Also, if you use credit a lot(we do for travel, carry less cash) there is ONE card that charges -0- transaction fees. That is all personal preference. You betcha we have it. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

yesterday I got 200Euro out at KSK in Bitburg, it cost me $241 USD if I got it at Community bank I would have gotten € 194.59 for the same amount of USD so I got 5,41 more Euro for my same amount of cash.......which is what, about a bit over $6 in savings right there 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

rant

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Spang Underground