Spang Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Spang bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent in Spang courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Rant/Advice

who's talking here?

Renee 3
Mom of 1 1
KMC 1
Shae 5
Jaymee 1
Ashley 4
amviolet98 1
Christina 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Christina --- 16 years ago -

Ok so I'm getting really irritated with my puppy. I take her out to let her do her business and I'm out there for a good while so she can do both. Well lately she hasn't been pooping outside. Whenever I bring her in a couple of minutes later she poops on the floor. Well today was the day it really got to me. I was outside with her for a good 15/20 min and she didn't go so I put her in her cage. Then about 30 min later I took her out again no pooping. So I let her eat and put her back in the cage and took my son to the cdc (gone for like 10 min). When I get back she pooped in her cage!! I mean really!! So I was mad cleaned it up and put her back in there. I let her back out before I picked up my son and when I got back she pooped in the cage again!! I'm about just to get rid of her, but I don't I really don't want to...she is just a puppy and I'm hoping she gets out of this soon. So I'm thinking on waiting till hubby gets home (in a couple of weeks) and see how that goes. How can I get my dog to poop outside instead of inside....and like I said before I take her out about every hour or so and I'm out there for a good 15 min. 

Jaymee --- 16 years ago -

try taking her for a walk. That is a sure way to get our dogs to poop. What breed is she some breeds are know to be difficult to potty train. 

Ashley --- 16 years ago -

Hi Christina, If the puppy is pooping in her cage then it is to big for her dogs/ puppies will not poop where they sleep so the idea is to kennel train them. I would try blocking half of the cage off. Also they puppy should only be eating twice a day and he/ she will have to go out about 20-25 minutes after he or she eats. water is the only thing that should be kept out all the time. I have potty trained dogs in the past and if you would like I would be more than happy to help you out. 

Ashley --- 16 years ago -

Another idea is to bring the dog outside and stay out there with her until she does her business and when she does you praise her with a small treat nothing that will take her a while to eat just something that wants her coming back for more that way she is encouraged to keep going outside. If you happen to catch her in the act you can immediately bring her outside to let her know thats where she should be going. Whatever you do do not scold the dog they do not understand. I know it's frustrating at times but like children it will get better. 

Christina --- 16 years ago -

Ashely thank you for the advice, and I've been doing what you wrote. I guess I'm just really frustrated and I know it is going to take time for her to get potty trained. Just wanted to see if there was something I'm missing. Thanks again though!! 

Mom of 1 --- 16 years ago -

Christina, our puppy is doing the same thing. She hasn't been peeing in the cage (that I know of) but for some reason she still poops in there and on our floor. Its very frustrating!!! 

KMC --- 16 years ago -

Have you tried running around with the puppy outside? I had a similar issue with my dog a while back, she wouldn't poop when we took her outside, then would go in the house later. If she didn't poop, we would run around the courtyard a few times and then she would go. A longer walk would usually do it as well. Also, if she seems to be pooping an abnormal amount, you might want to think about changing her food. 

Ashley --- 16 years ago -

Changing her food abruptly can also make her poop a lot. If you are going to change her food it needs to be gradual puppies are like children in the sense where you they have very sensitive stomachs I would mix a small amount of the new food and increase it slowly until it takes over completely. Puppies also eat everything in site it seems like which means they can often get worms not saying that she does yet but if the stool is watery and she eats way more then it seems like she should without gaining any weight or even appears to have a "pot belly" then worms could very well be the issue. 

Ashley --- 16 years ago -

I agree with KMC that walking longer could help to get the process going. 

Shae --- 16 years ago -

Puppies will learn, it takes alot of time and love, but dont give up!! Just make sure you actually walk her around when you talk her outside, that gets sure "pooping" going! I know with my dogs i used puppy pads the 1st couple of weeks and got them use to those but i have never kenneled a dog so I dont really know how that works. Just give her time and dont get to upset, she still is a puppy.. 

Renee --- 16 years ago -

Ok, guys, I've trained quite a few puppies and the one thing that has always worked for me is playing Alpha dog. Basically, if you read a little about dog psychology, you learn that they are pack animals - they understand the world with that pack animal mentality. They first need to know what their place in your "pack" is; most bad doggie behavior results from confusion about their place in the "pack". In a family home, the dog is the bottom of the pack, after the adults and children. When they poop in your house, they are showing disrespect for the whole pack and you have to be VERY clear that it is completely unacceptable. You can do that by showing the dog the accident, then put it on its back and hold it there while you growl at it in a low voice, staring it in the eye. I know it sounds crazy, but the dog will learn to respect you and your "territory" this way. You follow this with extensive praise and affection when the puppy goes to the bathroom outside, and a little treat doesn't hurt either, especially if you can do it immediately after they poop or pee outside. If you decide to use this method though, which coincides very well with crate training also, there are a few other rules. In order to reinforce the "pack" mentality, you have to avoid letting the dog do anything that would confuse it as to its place in the family, ie, don't ever let it be on top of you while playing, don't let them jump on you or other people, don't let the dog sit with you on the furniture, don't allow them to eat your food or eat while you're eating - they should always eat after the family does, and DON'T let them sleep in your bed. These things help them understand our world in their doggie brain way of thinking, and it has worked well for me, even with "problem" dogs. If you are consistent enough, you can even start getting them to poop and pee on command. Not that you only let them go when you feel like taking them out, but you establish a routine and they learn that this is the reason they are outside. Play time is different than pee time! While they are doing their business, you repeat praise, and the command, and pretty soon you can take them out, tell them "go poop" or whatever you'd like the command to be, and they instantly know that they are there for that purpose and do it. This approach works really well if you take a few things into consideration. Obviously, you have to be able to get the animal to go outside at least once or twice in order for them to begin to understand the concept, and it is also important to establish a routine, and for them to get plenty of exercise outside that is not related to going to the bathroom. Once they have it figured out, then you can combine bathroom time and play time, but at first it should be separate. SORRY, I know this is really long winded! Its hard to explain though, without being thorough! Some people do not agree with this method of training, but for me it has always resulted in wonderful family dogs that were well trained and well behaved. 

Shae --- 16 years ago -

Wow, I must be a very bad dog owner cuz I pretty much let them do everything you said not too, And I have very well trained and well behaved dogs too. I guess it just depends on how you go about raising your dogs. I dont disagree with you and i am not here to agrue which way is better, whatever works works. 

Shae --- 16 years ago -

I just realized that I looked like a smarta** and didnt mean to, I just wanted to make it clear my dogs sleep with me, eat with me, play outside when I take them potty and Sit with me infront of the tv on the couch. anyone that has ever met my dogs can say they are the most big hearted, loveable and very well trained dogs. 

Renee --- 16 years ago -

LOL! Shae, I don't think you're a smartass! I agree, you really have to do what works best for you. Dogs are a lot like kids in that different things work with different personalities. Most of our dogs have been rescue dogs, and had bad habits and "problems" when we brought them home, and that method seems to work especially well in that situation, and with dogs that are slow to learn. Also, once the training is done, you are able to lighten up a little on the rules, but they are most important during the training period so the dog has no confusion. 

Christina --- 16 years ago -

Wow Renee lol that was a lot. I kind of do the alpha dog thing like you explained, but I do let her on the furniture...not on the bed. And because she is a puppy (only three months) I'm training her that she can't have affection when she wants it. Now I know that kind of sounds harsh but what I mean is she cannot jump on me, try to get all over me, or move her way into my lap when she wants affection. I do give her affection and the reason I do this is because whenever my son comes to sit with me she has to come sit in my lap too, which I don't want her to become possessive. Now if you guys can teach me how to get her to go potty on command that would be awesome. I've heard some people and my friends do it to their dogs. It would be so great since the weather isn't too great right now. Harley (the puppy) is a pretty smart dog...she knows to stay out of the kitchen if we are eating, she sits, comes, and is starting to lay on command. 

Shae --- 16 years ago -

Well the way I did it, when my dogs were pups i would walk them on a timely basic and through out the walk i would say " go potty" and just keep saying it till they went then give them a treat and be like "ohhh gizmmo went potty good boy.. he went potty outside" lol i used alot of babytalk when i praised him.. and now when i go outside or i need them to go potty before the car ride, i just say "go potty" and they usually go.. you just gotta stick with it, Keep on her, and dont give up or feel like you have or she will sense that from you. I know whenever i walk the dogs before i leave, i walk them longer so they have more time to kinda.. walk the poop out of them lol.. i know weird but it works.. 

amviolet98 --- 16 years ago -

Wow Renee, great tips! Do you have any advice on how to introduce new baby to the family dog? 

Shae --- 16 years ago -

I didnt introduce a new baby but i did get a new puppy after 5yrs of my Dog being the only spoiled dog.. I just made it seem like it was his gift.. like a new toy or a treat.. and it worked pretty good! 

Renee --- 16 years ago -

amviolet, I have had to introduce two new babies to our family. The first was after we'd had just the two of us and our doggie for almost 7 years, so he was our kid, and he knew it! He was pretty jealous at first, but also very protective. It was kind of funny, he didn't like the baby, but God forbid if he was suspicious of anyone's intentions, because he was her guardian. He takes himself way too seriously! Anyway, I think we could have done better introducing the new baby, but she was our first and we were stressed etc. I've learned since then that possessiveness is a from of domination and we should not have allowed it... If you're going with the alpha dog style of training/interaction, then its important to establish the baby'e position above the dog from the beginning, i.e., make sure the dog is not allowed to treat the baby as if it is theirs or to dominate the baby in any way by growling, standing over it, or showing possessiveness. Do not put the baby down to give the dog affection, instead, if the dog asks for affection while you're holding the baby, either include the baby so the dog understands that the baby is an affection giver too, or, push the dog away, wait a few minutes, then when you are done with baby for a bit, give the dog affection afterward. This helps establish the baby's position in the "pack" as superior to the dog. I don't mean to sound like a know-it-all! I am definitely not a dog trainer, I've done a lot of research, worked with some trainers and had a lot of personal experience. This is just what has worked for me. Every dog is different, so you have to choose a method that you think will work best with their personality. Whatever method you choose, consistency is the most important part! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Spang Underground