Spang Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Spang bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent in Spang courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Is it ok?

who's talking here?

nonya 1
denver21 1
M'lissa 1
Cassie 2
WitnessProtectionProgram 3
Kristen 3
Jaymee 2
Cathleen 5
Girl from the south 1
LaurenB 1
J3nnif3r 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Cathleen --- 16 years ago -

What would you do if you found out that your and several other children were pointed out by a teacher? For example, "Students look here at Johnny's paper this is how not to do it" or "you can all thank Johnny because now you all get F's." Aren't children mostly impressionable? My gosh I know at my age if my teacher was to point me out in front of all my peers it would embarass me and I wouldn't want to return for fear it may happen again :-( 

Cassie --- 16 years ago -

I don't think its ok. You're right at their age that wold be very embarassing. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

That makes me mad. I am not really 'down' with the whole 'never tell a kid they are wrong' and 'everyone wins' crap to the extreme that they go now but there is a perfect example of why EXTREMES in anything do not work well. Why would anyone be so mean, especially a teacher? Aren't they supposed to at least kind of like kids? 

LaurenB --- 16 years ago -

That is ridiculous, as someone who is getting her degree in teaching, I would NEVER embarrass a child like that! I would schedule a conference with her and explain how you feel about the situation. 

M'lissa --- 16 years ago -

I would be pissed if someone did that to my child. I would talk to the principal or teacher about that. 

Cathleen --- 16 years ago -

I have a bad habbit of getting worked up and going off...so I don't usually go to the schools with problems. Today I thought I would apporach the situation differently (by staying calm.) I did go right into the school when I was told of what happened by my son and I listened to the teacher. I could see what he said was true (there was proof of what he said the teacher did.) I didn't have to say a word to the teacher. The teacher started explaining right when we walked in. My son told me the teacher points people out all the time. I told him the next time she points him out he is to go to the office and call me. I will either start pulling him until they get the idea or I will let the office know why I am there. Not sure yet... Pointing him or any other child out is not ok. 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

I agree... As with any situation, you set the standard (with the offender) first and punish second. You've set the standard with the teacher by letting her know that her actions are inexcusable. The next time it happens, whether out of bad habit or WHATEVER, she needs to be reported. SHE is supposed to be the positive influence on the future of our children.... and one simple negative instance can have such a profound impact on a young mind. :( 

WitnessProtectionProgram --- 16 years ago -

In my sons class, we (the parents) are supposed to initial this paper each day, the kids can not do it themselves. We are still in TLF and starting to look at a second vehicle and can only do it when my husband comes home. So we have forgotten to initial this paper twice. She has started to make him sit out during play time as punishment. Im not happy with this. I see it as a sign of a teacher who will punish a student when they are not happy with the parent. I don't agree with this especially when my son is developmentally delayed too. I would go talk to the teacher...who is your kids teacher? Is it a certain 1st grade teacher who resembles the mom from Everybody Loves Raymond? 

Jaymee --- 16 years ago -

What age are you talking about? Middle school/ High School not nearly as big of a deal. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

It will be interesting to see how this goes. 

Girl from the south --- 16 years ago -

You have a point. Now, it's been a few more years than I want to acknowledge since I was getting my education degree, however, I don't think that the laws have changed that much. There is a little thing called FERPA (Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act). This situation is borderline, but "Johnny's" paper is a "student record". Student records can not be disclosed without parental consent or to an authorized authority. When I was in college it was beaten into our heads that even a student's graded paper laying on our desk where others could see it was against FERPA. Now this is certainly not borderline on just being plain WRONG!!! And if the teacher felt it necessary to explain herself when she saw you, she knew she was wrong. As a teacher, I can tell you she won't like this, but it will make a point: Politely tell her "I respect your authority in your classroom. However, you will not belittle my child, or in any way make him feel embarrassed about his efforts as a student. If this happens again, I will take this to the principal." You are not telling her what to do, but telling her what you will do. The ball is then in her court. This just makes me sad, because there are so many out there who are great teachers. Educators like this give us all a BAD name!!! 

denver21 --- 16 years ago -

Cass, I think that teacher is retiring after this year from what I've heard. And if this is Spang Middle School, I'd love to know which teacher this is. Is this a science class, per chance??? 

WitnessProtectionProgram --- 16 years ago -

HAHA, thats awesome that you know who Im talking about. Ive always wondered if anyone else thought she looks like her too. Its good shes retiring, she was HORRIBLE and acted like she just hated teaching. Everytime I walked by her room, the kids always had the lights turned off and heads down on the desks. 

Cassie --- 16 years ago -

Jaymee you think its ok at middle and high school levels? I have to disagree, that is still a very sentitive time in a child's life. Especially middle school 

Jaymee --- 16 years ago -

I didn't say it was OK I just said it wasn't as big of a deal. You have to deal with things differently. I wouldn't go directly to the teacher in upper grades I would try and teach my child how to deal with it. They have to learn how to handle situations too. 

Cathleen --- 16 years ago -

Of course with anything it depends on the child/person. My son is in middle school and he is a pretty tough kid. Nevertheless, when I picked him up from school he was crying (well face red and teary.) When we went into talk to her the teacher asked him "what put him over the edge?" He shrugged his shoulders. He told us afterwards that he wanted to respond to her "you did" but he said afraid of reprucussions. He also gave another example about another child. I asked him what did that child say/do/think and he said the other kid said he doesn't care. My son also commented that sometimes she's cool (she got him into some great books) but he doesn't like her because of how he and others are treated. He says she hates him. BTW, he said she only points boys out never girls. 

Cathleen --- 16 years ago -

 

nonya --- 16 years ago -

Cathleen, looks like your son finally got a taste of his own medicine. 

WitnessProtectionProgram --- 16 years ago -

You know her son? 

Cathleen --- 16 years ago -

What medicine would that be? Interestingly enough...I haven't a clue who you are! ...hhmm really don't understand your statement. Bored?...just need to have some drama? Yes, actually it must be both that you are bored and like drama. BTW my son is NONYA Business! 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

Wow, that was outta nowhere. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Spang Underground