I've got a question! We sold a car to a guy and he signed a contract agreeing to make payments. Now for the second time in a row he's saying he can't pay until next month. Last month we had to go to legal because he decided he wasn't going to pay anymore payments at all. Legal told him he signed the contract and it was up to him to fulfill that agreement. Now this month he says he won't be able to pay until next month because his leave got approved and he needs to pay for his plane tickets. Do you think this is something worth taking to the shirt? I hate to get the shirt involved, but we have a loan of our own to pay (through a bank) that actually collects interest. We are able to make our payments, but still we are getting charged unnecessary interest because he can't make payments. What are your opinions...just wait until next month and hope for a payment or take it the shirt? Do you think the shirt will do anything about it or pretty much tell us 'sucks to be you?' I know they can't garnish his wages without a court order! ugh
I am not attacking you in anyway, but if our husbands were in the civilian world and this same situation happened to you, would you go to your husband's boss? Probably not. I wouldn't do it in this situation either. In any failure to pay a car note case, if the buyer fails to pay the car is simply repossesed. How many months has he failed to pay for the car? Did you put a repay date on your contract? If not, then you should wait for 4 months non-payment (just like through a bank), and then go back to legal to see about getting a repossession. At that point, legal would most likely have you contact the first shirt. At that point though, he has breached the contract and you will have legal to back you up. If he has only failed to pay 2 months, you may not have that easy of a time. Just my piece of advice.
He can afford to go on vacation but not pay his bills!? I agree about not normally going to a boss BUT if you can do something about it you should. Well at least I would. Legal won't help you again!? If not you should at least try the shirt. Or call Judge Judy haha!!!
Kevin-I know where you are coming from...I would not go to his boss in the civilian world, and that is why I said I hate to go to the shirt. But honestly in the civilian world we probably would not of allowed him to make payments. It sounds silly, but we were willing to allow him to make payments because we knew we would have legal and his job(the air force) backing us up. We do have a pay off date which is in April, but the bill of sale reads that he will make monthly payments...every month on the 15th. I just don't want April to roll around and him say 'oh i paid every month.' And then have legal have a problem with us not coming in to let them know what was going on. We do keep track of payments and give him receipts so I know he wouldn't win in court if he tries that, but that just starts a whole new problem that could be prevented.
RoxAnne-I thought the same thing. He says he already bought his plane tickets...but then he told us he needs the money from this coming paycheck to pay for his plane tickets. So he can take out a loan for plane tickets but not for his car! Last time we were in at legal they told us that he was in the wrong and we should take it to the shirt...so now I don't know if we should go back to legal or just go straight to the shirt! Lesson learned don't allow people to make payments!!! We should be charging him interest...maybe then he'd be a little more willing to pay on time.
Well if legal told you to take it to the shirt then do so. If you dont and April comes along I am sure you will get asked why you waited so long to let them in on the problem. At least this way they will be aware of it in case the situation escalates!
Work the chain of command. The AD person needs to talk to his/her own supervisor and explain the situation. Then approach this guy's supervisor. That way if it is still necessary to approach his shirt, you won't receive flack for jumping ship and going over their heads. He is under a legal binding contract. There is no reason why they shouldn't have your back. AND this guy could end up with some form of paperwork (which sounds like he needs it!!!)
If you push it soon enough, his leave can be revoked because he isn't taking care of his financial obligations first. Thus freeing up some of his funds to pay you!
Good luck!!!
Tell him hops are free and to give you your cash haha. I don't agree with waiting four months to take some form of action. It sounds like he is just wanting to get a free car ( don't we all) and he doesn't seem to think he should have to live up to his legal obligations. I agree with Gina go up the chain and see what they will do for you one way or another he has to give you the money you agreed upon I would also get everything in writing or I would record him telling you he isn't paying you anything or the fact that he is going to spend his money or things he wants instead of paying you, you can never be to careful.
He's not living by the civlian rules, and neither does your husband or you for that matter. You are held to higher standards and everyone dealing with the miltary knows it. That means banks, credit card companies ect...they wouldn't hesitate to send a letter informing your chain of command that you are not making payments.
I say go to the first shirt, this is part of what they are there for.
I hope your credit isn't hurt too badly by all of this!
Well, I will have to change my stance on this if legal gave you the advice to go to his shirt. I would follow their advice and do such. You could try telling the guy that you will be going to his shirt as a heads up...maybe then he will pay it!
I don't agree living in the military has us being held to a higher standard. I think all too often military members and their families rely too much on the military to "help them out" of situations....WIC, free child care, food stamps, legal, financial and any other personal problems that are difficult to solve on your own. I believe this is why we have some of the problems that we do! Just my opinion....
When some one does something wrong, there are way to go about it to "show them the light" instead of making it something that will follow them always. Being taken to court or her credit being ruined will follow them past the military. The guy is LUCKY that the first shirt could be involved. If she took him to court, she could sue for a number of things. The amount he agreed to pay, damages her credit had taken, the costs of the legal fees. You think the military wouldn't hear about all of that anyway? So he would still be "told on" and have a ton of money to owe over what the car payments were. Taking it to the first shirt, if this is his first offense, he might get a slap on the wrist or have paperwork that would dissappear when he moved to a different base. If this is not his first offense, he should answer for the things he keeps doing to other people.
There are some cases that the military is held to higher standard than civilians. But by the sound of it, you would like to held to higher standard all around. WIC and food stamps are something any american can get if needed, thats got nothing to do with just being military. Some of the pay you get early on, and if you have a family that early on, is not very much. Things don't always go as planned so thats why theses programs are there for every american.
Well our credit thankfully is not hurting at all. We are still able to make extra payments every month, but those extra-extra payments we would be able to make if he paid us would be nice. I'm just not sure if we should go back to legal and explain his new excuse for not paying or just go straight to the shirt this time. I maybe wouldn't have a probably with him making a late payment if he hadn't tried to get out of the payment last month. Last month he wanted to give us back the car and for us to give him all his money back AFTER he drove the car for a month. He bought the car "as is" knowing everything that was wrong with it. He also had our phone number down for his insurance (I have no idea why) and we got a call that the car had been in an accident. I have a feeling he's just trying to get money from everywhere to pay for this vacation. I hate to make it sound like he is a bad person because I don't know him personally, but he's doing some really shady things. And yes we are keeping everything documented. He won't call us and tell us this...he emails us...so really he's documenting it himself!
Tell him he has to pay, just like a bank would. If he can afford vacation he needs to make the car payment. You should tell him its unacceptable and that if he can't afford it, then he needs to give you the car back. If we were stateside, it would be different, inform him, then go to the first shirt. You should maybe talk to your first shirt first. If you are easy on him, he will walk all over you. We know he is getting paid, so there is no excuse. you don't get to not pay something to go on vacation.
We DID tell him we were going to the shirt and he said "Ok well that's not going to make money magically appear!" That just pushed it over the top...now I just really hope they cancel his leave. Although I don't see that happening because he leaves Sunday!
I would contact your first shirt, explain it to him and ask him what to do. I would do it ASAP if he is leaving Sunday, its BS, he would be charged a late fee or have the car repossessed if it were a bank. I would take care of it sooner than later. Its sad that you gave him the benefit of the doubt and he is taking advantage of it.
It sounds to me as if he is a very irresponsible person and has his priorities mixed up. You were nice enough to allow him to make payments, he needs to hold up his end of the bargain. In my opinion, whatever you do at this point, you are fully justified in doing. You have fairly warned him that you will take it up the chain of command, and his answer was flippant and uncommunicative, so go ahead and take it on up!
"Ok well that's not going to make money magically appear!"
WOW!!! I hope his tickets are REFUNDABLE!!! That's just unacceptable! And it's Monday....PLENTY of time to hit two buttons and a computer and make him stay home......
KEVIN I think all too often military members and their families rely too much on the military to "help them out" of situations....WIC, free child care, food stamps, legal, financial and any other personal problems that are difficult to solve on your own. Really??? I mean....REALLY??? Wow!
We're not military, but I would think that the shirt could have some pull with finance to have the money taken out of his check (worst case scenario.) I mean, there's a legal, binding contract involved...
I beg to differ...
Question to military associated...have you ever been turned down for a loan? YES?! Well thats because the military doesn't have the pull it used to with active duty. So companies no longer give out loans to you if your finances don't show that you can't pay it.
Rightfully so...I have a mommy and daddy and I don't need the military or first shirt being mine! We all make decisions as adults and mommy and daddy can't always make us do what they want us too.
I agree... I think she should definitely go to the shirt. The individual's priorities are definitely not in order if he signed a contract stating he would pay for a vehicle in monthly installments, and then decides to go on vacation afterwards, placing him in financial jeopardy.
I do know people who have lost rank in the military because they were not responsible with their finances. Not only this, but financial institutions can and will contact the military chain of command when the military member fails to pay.
It's not about mommies and daddies and someone forcing you to do what you're supposed to do. It's about enforcing a legality... This is law... it trumps right/wrong :)
Call Vito, he is more effective, then turn his bloody pulp of a body into the military and see if they still can use him
oh yeah but yes, as a few of us said,.........repo first
Cathleen, I agree to some extent - none of us want the military up our butts all the time and in all our personal affairs. BUT, if we take care of things as we should, and are honest and responsible, as we should be, they won't have any reason to be in our personal business. They have every right to hold people accountable for their actions. Its not about "mommy and daddy" its about upholding a standard.
I think more and more of the story is coming out the more the posts are put up. It sounds like you don't want to repo you want to make him pay. I honestly don't see the military enforcing that. Chances are they will just make him give the vehicle back.....unfortunately you will get the short end of the stick but that is the breaks when you do a side deal. Noone is judging you for doing that (I probably would have done the same thing), however in the end you take a risk of taking a hit as well.
Just an FYI...going to court doesn't really help either. I had a case where someones child threw a rock at my brand new vehicle (literally 30 minutes off the lot) and I took them to court. Won a judgement however she still failed to pay and there is nothing the courts can do about it except put it on her credit score for 7 years. So in that case where something was nowhere near my fault, I still lost in the end by paying the 400 dollars in court costs!
Either way, I would get some answers by Sunday!! I think a repossession is your best option and take the loss of him driving it for a month.
I would repo too, but if its been in an accident, you're definitely going to get screwed. And don't pay him anything he has paid. Tell him if he does not pay by Saturday, you're coming to get it.
He sounds like a shady character, I wouldn't tell him your're going to come get it because he might hide it or do something to it. Just give him a dealine then go get it back. Its what I would do anyway.
Im pretty sure there is a "process" to repoing a car.
I wouldn't do it unless you are sure you are not going to get in trouble.
Does he already have the title??