Ok so... professional photography is your career of choice. You have a client who comes to you and wants photographs done. You notice something a bit "unphotogenic" about the individual, but you agree to do the shoot anyway. You know that NO amount of editing is going to fix the flaw in the picture... How do you tactfully let the individual know that these pictures aren't very good? I mean, do you pretend that they're awesome, just to keep your client and to make him/her feel better about themselves? Furthermore, do you post them in your portfolio and claim them to be among your best work?
What's your opinion?
Age old saying... Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. I am sure what ever is unphotogenic they already know about. If it is as good as you can make it you have done your job.
Agreed! You as the photographer must do your best work and if it is your best work then you put it in your portfolio. If it isn't amongst your best work you don't put it in your portfolio. I am not a photogragher but I wouldn't think that the criteria behind it is "only pretty people". Your portfolio though is a representation of your work and if you aren't confident in your work(By means that you don't think they are the best looking photos you have taken), which is what should be in your portfolio then you shouldn't put those particular pictures in the portfolio. Also it is your portfolio and you do not need to explain to someone you did a service for why they aren't in it. But...YES! to the persons face while you are taking the pictures you pretend they are awesome. Because making someone feel awesome will give better pictures and a person taking pictures needs something/someone to feed off of. It is not very easy to just sit and smile, etc. without some sort of help. It is not ok to hurt people's feeling whether they know or don't know they are or aren't "photogenic."
Here are a few thoughts coming from a fellow photographer:
1) I believe everyone is beautiful in their own way. Whether you see it or not. It may be in their personality, or in how they carry themselves, or their exterior appearance. Either way, everyone has some one in their life that think they are perfect the way they are.
2) Everyone deserves to have their photo taken if they want. If photographers were constantly turning people away because they saw something "unphotogenic" about them, there'd be far less people getting photos taken, and we'd all be out of a job. I know there'd never be anyone wanting to take my photo!
3) I've found that a lot of people already know about their unphotogenic aspects, but are comfortable in who they are. I've met several people who have requested I not edit certain things out. Just as an example-I have pregnant clients with lots of stretch marks asking me to just leave them, because they have them and they're beautiful because that's how they really are. That's just one example.
4) When in a session-I always focus on the personality of the person. If you bring out the personality of the person, I think they can look amazing regardless of their true outer appearance because they are being who they are. And the people who see the photos, and know them will see that.
5) I always let my clients judge for themselves if they are happy with a session. I don't give my bias when showing them proofs. I have had many sessions that I was unhappy with, but clients loved, and vice versa. You don't have to do any pretending at all. Be who you are, let them be who they are, and it will work out how it's supposed. I think "pretending" in hopes of keeping clients is not a good idea.
6) I don't think every shoot has to go in your portfolio. Post what you are happy with. But, I also wouldn't not put something up because you don't like how the person looks. Jaymee is exactly right here-beauty is in the eye of the beholder, and if you capture personality-I think that is most important.
Just my thoughts.
Do you let the individual know that the pictures aren't very good? No, you just do your job. You don't pretend they're awesome. You just do your job. You doing your job and being professional about it will make them feel better about themselves. And your portfolio is of your choosing. If you don't think they're your best work, then don't put it in there. Bottom line--do your job and don't post things on here that the individual in question could read and then go slice their wrists open because of the seemingly hypothetical comments you just made about them.
Thanks! Don't worry, I haven't turned any clients away because I didn't think they were ugly :P I've just been in situations before where there were qualities about a photo that I didn't think would work and I didn't know what/if I should tell the clients for fear of hurting their feelings.
They know, they look in the mirror every day.
I am positive that you should say nothing if they don't. I would not even airbrush or try to touch it up unless they ask.
Well, first Ill state the obvious: its your portfolio and completely up to you which pictures you choose to include and exclude.
You have a client who comes to you and wants photographs done. You notice something a bit "unphotogenic" about the individual, but you agree to do the shoot anyway.
Ive never been to a professional photographer; however, I had no idea that they decided on which clients they would take based on any sort of attractiveness scale.
You know that NO amount of editing is going to fix the flaw in the picture
Obviously, I dont know your client or if they even asked for the flaw to be fixed. Even so, why would you assume that a person wants that flaw fixed for them? Maybe it isnt even a flaw to them.
Trust me, most people (particularly women and young girls) are well aware of actual (and perceived) flaws to their bodies. I know that if I show my teeth while smiling, it looks like half of my face has been engulfed by my mouth. I know that although my hips arent massively huge, they are definitely out-of-proportion to the rest of my body. Guess what? Even with my toothy smile and somewhat large hips, those that love me most (my husband, kids, and mom) think that I am beautiful and very photogenic. Just as Im sure you see your husband and kids as beautiful and photogenic (flaws and all). I dont know you, so if youre not married or dont have children, you can replace husband and kids with mom, dad, etc.
How do you tactfully let the individual know that these pictures aren't very good?
Maybe they are good to them.
I mean, do you pretend that they're awesome, just to keep your client and to make him/her feel better about themselves?
What made you assume they arent awesome to them?
With that said, why in the world would you even consider hurting someones feelings? That is just basic human kindness. Although I know that I have unintentioally said things that hurt someones feelings before, I cant even imagine debating if I should intentionally say something that ugly to someone. Do we really need our chosen photographer making judgments on if we are awesome looking in a picture? Not to mention, this is a very small community. Although you didnt mention your client by name, it sure would make me feel bad had I just had my pictures taken by you and read this.
Wish I could get that stupid Italicize button figured out! Everything I want italicized comes out regular font and vice versa! Hence, my entire post coming out italicized! Sorry, I know that is annoying!
Well FORTUNATELY, I haven't done anything wrong... This post was merely an opinion gathering "poll" to see what the majority would do if in my situation.
Kayla hit the nail on the head with the stretch marks example. (Thank you Kayla) I HAVE had a session where the lady had stretch marks and was a bit shy about them and asked if they could be edited out. What if, in the future, I have a client who has terrible stretch marks, but is wanting quality, fine art photographs - just like the ones you see taken by GREAT photographers worldwide? Do you let this individual know that it's impossibile to edit out her stretch marks... Or that because of the severity of them, she's not going to get the photographs that she might be envisioning... That was all I was asking!
Don't just automatically assume, Jana... that the person I am on here is the same person I am when dealing with photography clients. I try to be extremely professional when photographing people and that's WHY I'm going out and getting the opinions of possible FUTURE clients as well as fellow photographers.
I would think that anyone considering a photographer who MIGHT see this would appreciate that the "inexperienced" photographer had the tact to ask about this possible situation.
Yay, lets turn this into a "bash Jennifer" forum. *rolling eyes*