I guess it would just depend on the original reason for the c-section. I think doctors are too quick to opt for a c-section. There are lots of women who have sucessful VBACs. You have to do what you feel is best for yourself and your baby at the time.
As my OB/GYN said "Americans are too quick with a knife." (He mentioned this when I told him that I'd tried to talk my hubby into a vasectomy!) He shook his head and said no no no no... if you want birth control, we can discuss it - but I don't suggest doing stuff that is permanent.
I would ONLY defy a doctor's wishes if I'd done thorough research and thought that I was truly doing what was best for myself and my baby.
I have strong feelings on this one. I think women should have the right to choose a vbac if they so desire. This was recently a big issue back in WA, which outlawed vbacs about 3(?) years ago. Women I new personally were traveling to other states so they had the option of delivering their babies vaginally. Both of them came through it with no problems and healthy babies. The main reason that hospitals deny them is because of the insurance risk. If you look at the article, you can see that the risk of a rupture, especially on women who have only had 1-2 c-sections is very low, but because Americans are so sue-happy and because hospitals don't want to take ANY risks, they simply say "no". If doctors and hospitals had it their way, we'd all still be giving birth in sterile rooms on our backs because it's "safer".
Well, it sounds like she researched it and she did what was best for her or what she suspected was best for her and the baby. I would have been to scared to do it! 20 hours of labor....OH GOD NO!!
Why not just have the mother sign a liability release form or something... that way she proves that she KNEW the risks involved, and she releases the hospital from any responsibility should anything happen...
I have to agree Jen. I secretly loved them while we had to use them after the hubby's vsec. For once *I* was the one who could just role over and go to sleep! LOL!
OMG this convo was nuts!! You late nighters are dirty!
I agree with pretty much all that was said. I researched birth stuff a lot before having my two, and was really saddened to see how docs push women into medical procedures for fear of litigation. The medical professional in America feels there is no difference int he actual birth experience; as long as you end up with a healthy baby, who cares how it got there? They totally disregard the emotional connections for a woman as well as the physical and chemical reactions that happen when a woman actually pushes a baby out of the birth canal. There is a high correlation between c-sections and post-partum depression, as well as between c-sections and difficulty breastfeeding. Sigh. Birthing in America is all screwed up.
As far as condoms...wow. You guys put it all out there, didn't you? LOL!
I would never disregard what my Doctor or Midwife would tell me. Never. The health of the baby, and my health comes first (it's Marco's wife talking here). I just feel sad that there has been this huge explosion in 'birth fetishism' over the past few years. Too many women who require c-sections are made to feel like faliures for having one. And what I find really scary - Freebirthing. Shunning all pre and post-natal care. No midwife. No doctor. I know a woman whose child is permanently brain damaged after a freebirth. I'm sorry, but it's an issue I feel strongly about. Listening to medical professionals is more important than ones' ideals.